Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:04:47-2:05:15

Can extra battlecruisers simply offset Jutland losses?

The larger British force cannot be treated as a simple replacement pool because its first major battle would change whether and how a later Jutland occurred.

Alternate HistoryBattle Of Dogger Bank 1915Battle Of JutlandBattlecruisersForce Structure
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Would one Tiger, one Queen Mary, four Lions, one Indefatigable, and three Invincibles simply negate Britain's historical battlecruiser losses at Jutland?

Short answer

No simple subtraction works, because the altered force changes Dogger Bank first and may prevent a historical Jutland from occurring at all.

Notes

A count of extra British battlecruisers cannot establish how losses at a later Jutland would compare. Dogger Bank comes first in the changed fleet's wartime service. More capable ships could change that earlier battle and the naval situation that followed it. Jutland's occurrence and losses therefore cannot be held fixed while assessing the new force.