Video

Number 13 Class: Dreams of Yamatos - Key Ship Series 4, Ship 6

Study Number 13 Class: Dreams of Yamatos - Key Ship Series 4, Ship 6, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 14 Aug 2023, with 21 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battleships, Japanese Navy.

Date
Runtime49:41
Guide points21 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:02
    Number 13 in Japan's Eight-Eight Fleet

    The proposed Number 13 class emerges as the fast, 18-inch-gunned successor to Japan's Nagato, Amagi, and Kii programmes.

    Chapter
  2. 3:01
    Why Number 13 cannot be called the world's strongest

    Claims that Number 13 would have been unrivalled depend on unknown American and British successor designs.

    Notable Point
  3. 5:22
    Industrial preparation made the design plausible

    Japan was planning the yard and maintenance capacity for Number 13, making it more than a paper super-battleship.

    Notable Point
  4. 6:02
    More Daring-class destroyers and postwar naval presence

    A brief counterfactual asks whether completing more Daring-class destroyers would have preserved a larger Royal Navy escort and presence force.

    Notable Point
  5. 7:14
    A delayed treaty system changes battleship baselines

    If treaty limits arrived after Number 13 and its rivals, high speed and heavier guns could become the new capital-ship norm.

    Chapter
  6. 9:23
    A later naval treaty does not remove the political crises

    The shipbuilding counterfactual is bounded by the argument that fascism, militarism, and Japan's internal divisions would still shape the interwar world.

    Notable Point
  7. 11:28
    The Eight-Eight Fleet as a costly defensive target

    Japan wanted the battle line to make intervention costly for stronger industrial powers and deter a prolonged war.

    Chapter
  8. 13:27
    British imperial manpower complicated Japanese deterrence

    Japan had to reckon with Britain as both a naval power and the head of an imperial system able to mobilize forces from several regions.

    Notable Point
  9. 15:02
    Civil War veterans shaped Japanese views of U.S. cohesion

    Former Union and Confederate officers employed in Japan gave Japanese planners an unusual perspective on American political solidarity.

    Notable Point
  10. 16:43
    Number 13's 18-inch, 50-calibre striking power

    Number 13's proposed guns combined enormous shell energy with a calibre large enough to push rival navies toward still more extreme weapons.

    Notable Point
  11. 18:42
    Calibre, rate of fire, and turret handling

    The ten-inch-gun analogy shows how slower loading, turret movement, and spotting can erase the theoretical advantage of a larger shell.

    Notable Point
  12. 22:39
    Hiraga's design lineage from Nagato to Number 13

    The design is traced from the Queen Elizabeth fast-battleship idea through Japan's Nagato, Amagi, and Kii family and Yuzuru Hiraga's work.

    Notable Point
  13. 23:55
    Treaty interruption between Number 13 and Yamato

    Number 13 shows the pre-treaty capital-ship path Japan was preparing before two decades of construction limits led toward Yamato.

    Notable Point
  14. 25:19
    A visible fast battleship as deterrence

    Number 13 is imagined as a visible fleet cornerstone, contrasting with the limited deterrent value of a hidden prestige ship.

    Chapter
  15. 28:27
    The Eight-Eight Fleet as shield and sledgehammer

    Japan weighed the fleet's cost honestly while recognizing that a force defensive against great powers could be coercive against weaker states.

    Notable Point
  16. 31:20
    Using a simulation to test a hypothetical design

    A modernized game model preserves Number 13's intended speed and guns while making its displacement and stability compromises explicit.

    Notable Point
  17. 33:09
    Speed, range control, and South Dakota's twelve guns

    Number 13's 30-knot speed could keep a 23-knot South Dakota at long range, but damage would quickly erode that advantage.

    Notable Point
  18. 37:28
    Shell volume can outweigh larger calibre

    The simulation illustrates why more smaller guns and a faster firing cycle can overwhelm a smaller battery of very large guns.

    Notable Point
  19. 40:00
    Why a duel cannot represent the whole battle line

    A realistic comparison would require entire battle lines and cruiser forces, not one Number 13 fighting one South Dakota.

    Notable Point
  20. 42:37
    What a historical simulation can and cannot show

    Historical simulations are useful illustrations of choices and constraints, not definitive answers to an unrealized arms race.

    Notable Point
  21. 46:38
    Modernising Number 13 with Yamato-era armour

    A brief postscript imagines rebuilding Number 13 with Yamato-level protection as a route to a late-1930s Japanese fast battleship.

    Notable Point