Video
Check Campaign 11: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 11: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 1 Apr 2024, with 23 time notes. Topics include Anti-Submarine Warfare, Naval Gunnery…
Time notes
- 4:44Why cruiser submarines remained a poor bargainNotable Point
A brief aside rejects the idea that fitting six-inch guns made cruiser submarines a successful warship type.
- 13:02Designing a fleet to avoid fair fightsNotable Point
A deliberately one-sided engagement illustrates why force construction should create favorable battles rather than merely prepare for equal ones.
- 15:15How treaty escalation clauses opened the way to larger cruisersNotable Point
A ship's size is explained through the point at which treaty limits weakened and escalation clauses permitted larger cruiser designs.
- 31:17QuestionWere U.S. Bureau of Ordnance staff ever suspected of being enemy agents because the Mark 13 torpedo performed so badly?AnswerQ&A
No. The failures were treated as incompetence and inadequate testing rather than enemy sabotage. Once properly tested and corrected, the Mark 13 became effective.
- 45:08Setting the requirements for an 80,000-ton counterfactual battleshipChapter
The exercise begins with an 80,000-ton hull, sixteen 16.5-inch guns, and 30 knots, then exposes the constraints hidden inside that extreme specification.
- 55:40Trading range and speed for battleship stability and protectionNotable Point
Deck and belt protection compete with range, speed, pitch, and weight distribution as the oversized battleship is made capable of firing while under way.
- 1:03:48How battleship layout links firing arcs to hull balanceNotable Point
Moving turrets, funnels, and machinery improves pitch and weight distribution only if the main battery retains useful forward firing arcs.
- 1:11:36Treaty compliance and naval creative accountingNotable Point
Nominal treaty compliance could conceal design allowances, accounting choices, and interpretations that followed the letter more closely than the spirit.
- 1:17:20QuestionHow should battleship gun size be balanced against rate of fire?AnswerQ&A
The proposed 16.5-inch G3 gun was near a practical sweet spot: larger weapons improved penetration but fired too slowly for effective spotting correction, while smaller guns risked inadequate penetration against heavy armour.
- 1:20:09Why capturing a port still requires sea liftNotable Point
Airborne forces can raid or reinforce, but taking and sustaining a defended port demands heavy equipment and supply capacity that normally must arrive by sea.
- 1:21:47Why battleships carried heavy secondary batteriesNotable Point
Six-inch secondary guns give a battle line the volume of fire needed to stop cruisers and destroyers before they reach torpedo range.
- 1:28:09Concentrating a fleet instead of losing it piecemealNotable Point
A campaign encounter illustrates the danger of feeding small forces into a dominant battle fleet instead of massing strength or choosing weaker targets.
- 1:33:56How complementary battleship divisions create layered firepowerNotable Point
Two battleship classes are grouped so heavy guns dominate at range while their combined six-inch batteries protect the formation against light forces closing in.
- 1:42:30Using the Panama Canal to shift a fleet between theatresNotable Point
A campaign fleet can move from captured French Pacific islands through the Panama Canal to attack Caribbean possessions, making the canal central to operations across two oceans.
- 1:47:32Measuring naval strength beyond the number of shipsNotable Point
Campaign statistics compare hull counts with tonnage, ship types, budgets, crew pools, and logistics to show why one headline total cannot describe military strength.
- 1:54:13Matching a fast anti-submarine cruiser to its battle fleetChapter
The next anti-submarine cruiser is conceived as a large destroyer fast enough to accompany the newer battleships it must protect.
- 1:58:59Balancing machinery, survivability, and torpedoes in an ASW cruiserNotable Point
Machinery efficiency, damage control, deck protection, stability, and an eight-torpedo broadside compete inside the fast escort's limited displacement.
- 2:11:51How repairs and refits compete with new ship constructionNotable Point
Five battleships under repair and six more in refit explain why a fleet can have no new hulls building while its shipyards remain heavily committed.
- 2:16:11Why closing a defended strait can simplify enemy gunneryNotable Point
Sailing close past coastal guns may increase turret-tracking demands, but it also makes a ship easier to spot and turns long-range aiming into near point-blank shooting.
- 2:17:58How repeated battles can widen a fleet's quality advantageNotable Point
Repeatedly sending opponents against the same veteran battle fleet compounds its advantage through accuracy, aiming, reload, and damage-control experience.
- 2:19:46Matching gun power to targets in a fleet actionNotable Point
Heavy cruisers armed with 10.3-inch guns have little prospect against heavily armored battleships, making destroyers and light cruisers the more realistic targets.
- 2:22:50Cradock and the doctrinal pressure not to withdrawNotable Point
A comparison with Admiral Cradock highlights how Royal Navy doctrine and training could make withdrawal from an unfavorable action institutionally difficult.
- 2:30:02Ordering four battleships beyond the campaign budgetNotable Point
Four battleships add 428,000 tons of construction and roughly half a million in monthly spending, deliberately pushing the campaign programme beyond a prudent budget.