Video

Bruships 189: Naval History Questions Answered Live...continued

Study Bruships 189: Naval History Questions Answered Live...continued, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 13 Apr 2025, with 26 time notes. Topics include Live Q&A, Naval History, Naval Industrial Base.

Date
Runtime1:07:57
Guide points26 time notes

Time notes

  1. 1:37
    QuestionWhat books give a good account of naval logistics during the Scramble for Africa and other late nineteenth-century colonial expansion?Answer

    Use several works spanning British military power and naval history, because the Scramble for Africa grew from earlier economic and imperial developments.

    Q&A
  2. 5:10
    QuestionHow much large civilian shipbuilding could Germany undertake in the 1920s while improving infrastructure for ocean liners and cargo vessels?Answer

    The treaties did not directly limit civilian ships, but a conspicuous expansion could still provoke concern because the same infrastructure supported wider maritime power.

    Q&A
  3. 11:43
    QuestionWhat should the unfinished Kentucky and Hawaii have been completed as?Answer

    Complete them broadly as designed - Kentucky as an Iowa-class battleship and Hawaii as an Alaska-class large cruiser - unless willing to fund an expensive missile conversion.

    Q&A
  4. 14:12
    QuestionWas the often-mentioned Vickers gun salesman a real, identifiable person?Answer

    No specific individual is meant; the phrase summarizes Vickers' institutional lobbying for 14-inch guns during the naval-treaty period.

    Q&A
  5. 15:34
    QuestionWere any naval technological advances adopted too late to realize their value?Answer

    Yes; some highly refined gunship-era systems matured just as the missile era reduced the payoff from further perfection.

    Q&A
  6. 18:57
    QuestionWas the later British 5-inch/50 gun the direct successor to the earlier 5.1-inch/50 project?Answer

    Not really; despite similar caliber and length labels, they were substantially different guns from different design generations.

    Q&A
  7. 19:47
    QuestionWhen was prize money last paid to Royal Navy crews for capturing ships?Answer

    Probably in the nineteenth century, perhaps during the Crimean War, although later rewards were described differently.

    Q&A
  8. 20:22
    QuestionWhat is the panel's view of the Royal Navy's Type 31 frigate?Answer

    It is a useful, affordable inner escort and presence ship whose role complements rather than duplicates Type 26 ASW frigates and air-defense destroyers.

    Q&A
  9. 25:10
    QuestionHow could Germany adjust the Deutschland-class design to build at least eight commerce raiders?Answer

    The real solution is to allocate shipyard capacity to them and accept that other capital ships will not be built; modest redesign cannot erase that industrial tradeoff.

    Q&A
  10. 26:16
    QuestionWhat were the most successful surface raiders, and does CSS Alabama count?Answer

    Age-of-Sail frigates are strong candidates. Modern commerce raiders and sea-controlling cruisers performed comparable merchant-interdiction work, but the response does not assess CSS Alabama separately.

    Q&A
  11. 27:10
    QuestionHow will the closure of major British steelmaking capacity affect the Royal Navy?Answer

    The Navy can continue importing suitable steel, but rebuilding domestic warship-grade capacity requires explicit procurement policy, investment, and higher cost.

    Q&A
  12. 29:28
    QuestionHow would an old armed trawler be classified if rebuilt with only a new power plant and sensors?Answer

    It would probably be an offshore patrol vessel; making it the equivalent of a monitor would require much more extensive modification.

    Q&A
  13. 29:47
    QuestionWithout naval treaty limits, might British industrial investment have made jet development begin sooner?Answer

    Possibly through indirect industrial spillovers, but naval treaties did not directly restrict aircraft and the two industries followed different development paths.

    Q&A
  14. 30:35
    QuestionHow widely were Vickers guns used, and which companies competed with Vickers?Answer

    Armstrong was the principal rival before the firms combined; both could sell complete military systems rather than only individual guns.

    Q&A
  15. 32:33
    QuestionWere contra-rotating propellers tried on carrier aircraft during the 1930s?Answer

    No; they became useful only as wartime and postwar engines reached much higher power.

    Q&A
  16. 33:22
    QuestionWhich British First World War ship designs were mistakes?Answer

    The Courageous-class large light cruisers as built and the Admiral class as originally conceived are the clearest examples.

    Q&A
  17. 34:00
    QuestionWould the Gloster Sea Meteor have been a poor first carrier jet if it had been needed during the war?Answer

    It would have been less than ideal but probably usable if necessity forced the issue.

    Q&A
  18. 34:17
    QuestionDid any navy test a discarding-sabot shell for a battleship-caliber gun?Answer

    No official program is identified, but early British and American work suggests tests may have explored high-velocity diving shells for underwater damage.

    Q&A
  19. 34:55
    QuestionWhy did the Soviet Northern Fleet maintain its larger ships so poorly?Answer

    Its bases were built around destroyers and could barely support a cruiser, leaving battleships beyond the fleet's logistical capacity.

    Q&A
  20. 35:47
    QuestionShould the Montana class carry twelve 16-inch guns or eight or nine 18-inch guns?Answer

    Use twelve mature 16-inch guns if they allow rapid construction; their rate of fire and the ability to field more ships outweigh waiting for 18-inch weapons.

    Q&A
  21. 40:12
    QuestionWould a properly radar-equipped M247 Sergeant York still serve today as a mass-produced anti-drone system?Answer

    Probably not in regular service, though stored vehicles could be useful emergency counter-drone assets for critical sites or wartime aid.

    Q&A
  22. 43:30
    QuestionWhat is the best overall barrel length for a battleship's main guns?Answer

    There is no single optimum: 42-45 calibers favors service life, while longer barrels improve range and accuracy but demand more maintenance.

    Q&A
  23. 45:26
    QuestionDoes China have a balanced fleet capable of a cross-strait invasion of Taiwan, and what would it still need?Answer

    Fleet balance alone cannot solve the defender's geography, decades of preparation, underwater threats, shipping congestion, and the uncontrollable economic and political escalation of war.

    Q&A
  24. 56:27
    QuestionWhat effect might a Taiwanese counterstrike have during a cross-strait war?Answer

    It is inherently uncertain: striking back could help survival but might lose international support and complicate ending the conflict.

    Q&A
  25. 57:02
    QuestionWhy did Britain not preserve one of its modern battleships?Answer

    The government failed to value preservation soon enough, scrapping Vanguard only shortly before accepting the case for saving Belfast.

    Q&A
  26. 58:52
    QuestionDid the US Navy's use of turbo-electric drive influence American locomotive builders?Answer

    Not directly; both applications grew from similar engineering logic and shared American industrial strengths in electrical systems.

    Q&A