Video

A Historical Possibility: Triple Turret Potentiality (Long Patrol)

Study A Historical Possibility: Triple Turret Potentiality (Long Patrol), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 29 Dec 2021, with 12 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battleships, Naval Archives.

Date
Runtime31:02
Guide points12 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:27
    A possible 1909 triple-gun turret

    A photograph of what may be a 14-inch triple turret opens a cautious investigation into whether Britain explored the idea before the First World War.

    Chapter
  2. 1:58
    Where a triple turret might fit in super-dreadnought design

    The proposed timing places triple turrets alongside the Orion and King George V classes, when 13.5-inch guns and ten-gun broadsides redefined British battleships.

    Notable Point
  3. 6:26
    Three triple turrets and the speed trade-off

    A game-aided design comparison tests 21-, 24-, and 27-knot battleships built around three triple 14-inch turrets.

    Chapter
  4. 7:24
    The 1907 constructors' course behind the F3-style layout

    The game design draws on F3 and related concepts discussed in a naval constructors' course whose class graduated in 1907 and included Stanley Goodall.

    Notable Point
  5. 10:37
    Turret production as fleet-level firepower

    The thought experiment asks whether slower-to-build triple turrets could nevertheless equip more hulls and increase total squadron firepower.

    Notable Point
  6. 13:32
    Range, machinery, and the cost of 24 knots

    Range and fuel assumptions show why a faster triple-turret ship would demand careful choices about displacement, horsepower, boilers, and crew.

    Notable Point
  7. 16:00
    Armament and fire-control choices behind the concept

    The hypothetical ship combines three triple 14-inch turrets with period-appropriate fire control, secondary guns, torpedo tubes, and modest armour changes.

    Notable Point
  8. 17:29
    The vulnerability cost of fewer, larger turrets

    Three triple turrets simplify a layout but make each hit more damaging, because one disabled mounting removes a third of the ship's main-battery firepower.

    Chapter
  9. 19:29
    All-forward guns and the Jutland torpedo problem

    Pre-treaty concepts behind the G3, M3, and Nelson layouts suggest how forward-firing main batteries might support a charge into a torpedo attack.

    Notable Point
  10. 22:03
    How the mystery turret could be traced in the archives

    The unverified photograph becomes a research plan spanning Vickers company records, a previous historian's papers, testing-ground material, and the National Archives.

    Notable Point
  11. 24:13
    Alternative triple- and twin-turret batteries

    The design exercise compares three triples, four triples, and mixed triple-and-twin batteries instead of assuming that one broadside arrangement was inevitable.

    Notable Point
  12. 26:01
    Why the Royal Navy may have kept twin turrets

    Established twin-turret practice, vulnerability concerns, and the logistics of changing gun calibre all make the historical choice more understandable.

    Chapter