Does possessing the most powerful warship stop mattering?
The prestige attached to the claim is judged enduring. Arbitrary category scores are rejected as a useful way to present warship comparisons.
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
British escort orders and gaps in shipbuilding
The first example is British escort procurement: further Type 23 orders could have sustained production into Type 45 construction, while a larger Type 45 programme with more missile cells is preferred.
Nuclear strike cruisers as carrier escorts
The unbuilt strike cruisers are assessed as a lost opportunity to provide nuclear-carrier escorts with an automatic 8-inch gun.
The larger Queen Elizabeth carrier alternative
A larger Queen Elizabeth design is reconsidered alongside the argument that choosing a middle-sized option might allow three carriers.
The commonality problem in a carrier-based F-111
The naval F-111 example examines how adapting a land-based aircraft for carriers could undermine expected parts commonality.
Proposed supersonic Buccaneer upgrades
Proposed Buccaneer S2B improvements are recalled as a route to a reinforced, supersonic aircraft with afterburners.
Criticism of India's ex-Baku carrier reconstruction
The case against India's ex-Baku acquisition centres on the expense of reconstructing an older, less capable carrier.
Alternatives to rebuilding India's ex-Baku carrier
The reply favours seeking a carrier elsewhere in general, rather than specifically endorsing the Queen Elizabeth design. The objections concern delays, escalating expense and the inherited limitations of the Soviet hull.
Submarine dock capacity and fragmented Astute construction
British attack-submarine problems are connected to inadequate dock availability, gaps between batches and limited commonality.
The recalled Astute module wiring error
The account is clarified as a wiring-orientation problem while a module was assembled upside down. It is a recollection, with the fourth Astute boat suggested tentatively.
Improvising stronger air defence for Force Z
The proposal adds available machine guns and experienced gunners, checks ammunition and clarifies fighter support. Extra 3.7-inch guns are rejected because they would require a separate logistical system, and the response also expands into concentrating more ships.
Could Hermes provide fighter cover for Force Z?
A few Sea Gladiators are considered potentially useful, but carrier and aircraft availability limit the proposal. The later check places Hermes in refit, so her participation is judged unlikely.
The air-support misunderstanding around Force Z
Different meanings of air support are used to explain why available Buffalo fighters were not understood as part of Force Z's protection.
Concentrating Force Z for a night attack on the invasion shipping
With advance knowledge of the invasion, the proposed Force Z response concentrates more ships and attacks the landing force at night.
Tiger cruisers and interwar destroyers in naval games
They bring less familiar Royal Navy ships to players' attention and prompt a comparison of Tiger-class cruisers with the standard interwar destroyer armament layout.
A French war against both sides in Spain
France would face difficult land operations and diplomatic pressure, while Spanish territories in Africa would probably suffer most.
Spanish battleships and Béarn in a French intervention
Avoiding their hazardous coastal missions might help them survive, but French attacks in port, including a possible Béarn air strike, could replace those dangers.
The opportunity for an earlier vertical-launch Sea Wolf
It could have put Sea Wolf on more ships and made combined short- and longer-range missile defences easier to arrange, subject to sensor integration and cost.
Naming the Type 42 and Type 22 combination
The name recalled is a 42/22 combination; widespread service use of the informal Type 64 label is disputed.
Rebuilding Implacable instead of Victorious
The larger, less heavily used Implacable is judged likely to have been cheaper and quicker to rebuild, potentially followed by its sister.
The Royal Navy's postwar Type numbering
The postwar Type system grouped a complicated mixture of frigates, destroyers and conversions by their intended roles.
Would improved Revenges have triple 15-inch turrets?
No. Twin 15-inch turrets are retained for that alternative design.
Mission-based Mk 41 loadouts and missile reserves
At least five complete reloads per ship are preferred, with each missile mix tailored to its mission and coordinated across the task group.
Royal Navy raids on enemy coastal shipping
The joke is accepted as a description of its attacks on French coastal shipping during the Napoleonic Wars.
Capital-ship main guns against aircraft
They could discourage aircraft from entering an area, but destructive direct hits were rare exceptions rather than dependable anti-aircraft performance.
Electronic warfare, drones and warship stealth
Extensive electronic warfare is already built into warships, while a broader mix of threats could encourage accepting a larger radar signature to carry more firepower.
Electronic-warfare pods on regular aircraft
Wider use of electronic-warfare pods on regular aircraft is considered plausible, and such pods have never entirely disappeared.
Why the experimental 16-inch/100 gun was unsuitable for ships
No. Its joined-barrel construction is described as unsuitable for a shipboard installation.
A reading recommendation for the Bismarck class
Koop's work on Bismarck is recommended.
Bismarck and Tirpitz: reputation and operations
The attention given to Bismarck and Tirpitz is compared with their short or limited operational careers and the effort spent trying to destroy them.
Tirpitz's deck armour and Operation Tungsten
The limited effect attributed to Barracuda armour-piercing bombs on Tirpitz illustrates the protection a battleship deck could provide.
Comparing Mediterranean air attacks with Pacific battles
The scale of air attack in the Mediterranean complicates an assumption that the largest naval air battles all occurred in the Pacific.
Falklands deterrence and submarine availability
The preferred approach is to maintain the garrison and make an attack submarine available, supported by sufficient submarines, dockyard capacity and sustained defence investment.
Falklands Typhoons and the retirement of Tranche 1
The retirement of the Falklands' Tranche 1 Typhoons is distinguished from the longer service expected of later Tranche 2 and 3 aircraft.
Retired aircraft can remain in the inventory
No. Aircraft can remain after formal retirement, although their retained roles and further upgrades depend on later decisions.
Falklands air defence and submarine deterrence
Falklands defence is described as a combination of fighters, ground-based air defence and the deterrent effect of an attack submarine.
Falklands rhetoric and domestic political pressure
Stronger Argentine rhetoric over the Falklands is interpreted as a response to economic difficulty and declining government popularity.
Falklands diplomacy and independent defence
The reported idea is assessed as having little immediate momentum. Uncertainty over allies' future interests supports a preference for maintaining independent armed forces.
The Falklands infantry garrison
It can be supplied by Royal Marines, paratroopers, Gurkhas or another light-infantry unit.
Reading about the initial defence of the Falklands
Ricky D. Phillips is recommended for work on the initial defending force, with attention drawn to disagreements with official accounts.
Counting the Falklands garrison and wider defence presence
That figure is treated as a count of the wider defence presence, including air, naval and civilian support personnel, rather than the infantry garrison alone.
Falklands mine clearance and residual uncertainty
Wartime Argentine minefields are recalled alongside the 2020 clearance announcement and expressed doubts about absolute certainty after clearance.
Comparing Channel Tunnel and HS2 delivery delays
The Channel Tunnel and HS2 are used as a brief comparison of the delivery delays attached to major British rail projects.
Devonport dock work and repeated promises of acceleration
Reports of faster work on Devonport docks 10 and 14 are met with scepticism based on earlier plans and conference presentations.
Smaller warships to complement Canada's Type 26s
Swedish and Finnish designs are preferred starting points, especially a strengthened-hull Swedish FDI variant suited to Canadian conditions. The training-ship part receives no separate recommendation.
Tiger and the last British gun-cruiser generation
Tiger's place among the last completed British gun cruisers makes its prominence understandable, while the mixed event may encourage interest in unusual ships.
Exploring alternative Type 31 weapons and sensors
An interchangeable Type 31 display model illustrates how different weapons and sensors can be explored on a common hull.
Dupleix-class armoured cruisers: battery and protection
They are judged reasonably good ships with a useful main battery and acceptable protection, although their secondary battery appears light.