Were capital ships' heavy main guns ever effective against aircraft?
Short answerThey could discourage aircraft from entering an area, but destructive direct hits were rare exceptions rather than dependable anti-aircraft performance.
NotesHeavy main guns could create an area that attacking aircraft preferred to avoid. Direct hits were exceptional and depended heavily on luck. One reported incident has a 16-inch shell striking the front of an Italian trimotor aircraft and collapsing its main structure. The possible record-range shot is presented as a rare event rather than a measure of routine effectiveness. The overall assessment gives these barrages more psychological than physical effect.