Heavy-lift ships for damaged warships
Modern semi-submersible heavy-lift ships would have been valuable in World War II, but only for especially important and expensive assets.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Vanguard and Warspite used the same gun type
The gun barrels were the same 15-inch/42 type, while Vanguard benefited from improved turrets and fire control.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Italian assault boats would invite rapid-fire defenses
Carrying MT assault boats with cruisers and battleships adds small attackers but also gives opponents an obvious reason to fit more rapid-fire guns.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A Japanese 510 mm gun was technically workable
Testing would not necessarily have discredited Japan's 510 mm gun, because roomy twin mountings and suitable machinery could handle it at a reduced rate of fire.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A secret 20-inch gun sacrifices deterrent value
An extreme-caliber gun has political value only if rivals know about it, which could provoke even larger-gun programs.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Super-heavy naval guns would devastate fixed shore targets
Twenty- or 24-inch shells would be especially destructive against fixed defiles, bridges, and armoured formations.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Britain rotated carriers through pilot training
Rather than rely on one dedicated training carrier, Britain used working-up, older, and escort carriers as circumstances allowed.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Handling 20-inch shells is a machinery problem
Larger shells require correspondingly stronger hoists, guides, and machinery rather than a fundamentally new handling principle.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A higher treaty ratio gives Japan more ships, not a new fleet concept
A better capital-ship ratio would probably enlarge Japan's historical fleet rather than transform its designs, while no treaty could unleash stronger Anglo-American building.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
An untreatied naval race would strain interwar France most
Italy might keep building from political ambition, but France would face a sharper conflict between naval status, imperial commitments, war recovery, and unstable interwar government.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Holding Narvik reshapes both Arctic and Atlantic convoy warfare
An Allied Narvik denies Germany northern Norwegian bases and sheltered routes, easing Arctic convoys while changing U-boat and surface-raider access to the Atlantic.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Holding Narvik could redirect Swedish iron ore into Allied steel
Buying high-grade Swedish ore through an Allied Narvik could deny it to Germany, improve British furnace throughput, and ease steel constraints on warship and merchant construction.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Coastal artillery can exceed shipboard gun limits
A fixed emplacement can support guns larger than a ship can carry because the land absorbs weight and recoil without stability or seakeeping penalties.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A captured alien carrier becomes a technical-intelligence raid
A Halo counterfactual becomes a lesson in rapidly stripping command spaces, sensors, weapons, craft, and material samples before a captured ship is destroyed.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Modern coastal batteries did not depend on medieval castles
Britain retained many coastal strongpoints, but new gun positions could be built wherever geography required them whether or not an old castle survived.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A timely warning changes Pearl Harbor's alert posture
Enough warning would put movable ships at sea, run radar continuously, disperse aircraft, and place both Navy and Army defenses on full alert.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Federal military power helped drive the US constitutional settlement
A tangent on the 1940 draft links the Constitution to weaknesses under the Articles of Confederation in federal military capacity and taxation.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A lieutenant could command a snow as master and commander
The vessel's commander would normally be a lieutenant exercising command responsibility comparable to the officer of a brig.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Weather gauge and flexible frigate groups in commerce raiding
Four or five frigates could disperse to hunt individual prizes or concentrate against a convoy, while the weather gauge helped them control an engagement.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A US withdrawal would delay rather than automatically end AUKUS submarines
The June 2025 discussion treats a US exit as a loss of interim Virginia-class boats and funding, while Britain could continue design sharing if production expanded.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Australia needs escorts and an industrial base as well as submarines
Submarines cannot protect trade alone, so Australia still needs surface escorts, shipbuilding skills, and enough independent strength to contribute to allied defense.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Why exact double-rescue figures for Dunkirk are elusive
The evacuation's improvised loading makes exact figures unavailable for troops rescued and then lost or rescued again after another vessel sank.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Navies recognized metal-hull fatigue early
Fatigue was already familiar from iron hulls, while conservative construction could keep stresses below damaging thresholds.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Battlecruiser labels require context
Alex Clarke and Drachinifel broadly agree on battlecruiser and fast-battleship categories, with nuanced disagreement over individual modernized ships.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Rejecting level bombing would shift aircraft toward torpedo attack
An earlier American realization that level bombing was ineffective against ships would favor torpedo-capable aircraft and weapons that cause flooding or uncontrollable fire.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Why Britain used manned electronic-warfare decoys
Drone decoys would have complicated an already crowded air battle and required large numbers, while Bomber Command achieved similar effects with manned support aircraft, jamming, and Window.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
The Royal Navy stored aviation fuel where the RAF did not expect it
Prewar naval fuel planning covered Fleet Air Arm needs at overseas bases, but it did not automatically create stocks for the much larger Royal Air Force.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
The Clyde engine would not extend the Wyvern's career
A reliable Clyde would make little difference, while the historical engine's destructive vibration problems could shorten the Wyvern's service.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Victorian sloops supplied global presence
Late-19th-century sloops were not powerful fleet combatants, but their range, availability, and delegated authority made them valuable worldwide.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Cruiser orders could double as recession employment policy
Before the treaty era, the Royal Navy answered recessions with cruiser proposals that created shipyard work while expanding global fleet capacity.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
An Iowa-class hull appearing in 1896
A modern Iowa-class hull appearing at USS Iowa's 1896 launch would overwhelm its yard and infrastructure while provoking a long Anglo-American design race.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Royal Navy submarines reached the Baltic's edges
After an initial correction, British submarines are described as operating into the Baltic's approaches and edges during the war.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Canadian Lincolns might not outlast the Lancaster
The newer Lincoln offered little extra value for Canada's coastal-patrol mission and could be retired alongside or even before the larger Lancaster fleet.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A full French Army revolt in 1916 threatens the state, not just an offensive
The outcome depends on whether troops merely refuse attacks or reject the government itself, because the latter could collapse the front, force a British withdrawal, and begin a French civil conflict.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Preventing the Halifax Explosion means stopping Imo's departure
Arriving in Halifax on 5 December 1917 leaves little time, making delay to Imo the most practical way to keep the ships from meeting in the Narrows.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
HMS Venturer made the only recorded submerged-on-submerged kill
The February 1945 sinking of U-864 off Norway remains the only publicly recorded case of one submerged submarine deliberately sinking another submerged submarine.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Britain was approaching an autoloading 4.5-inch mount before the war
Without tight ship-weight limits, prewar work on the 4.5-inch UD mounting could have produced a loading system close to contemporary ideas of an autoloader.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
The Royal Navy F4U-4C appears to have remained a paper proposal
The supposed British cannon-armed Corsair is traceable only to a single book reference, making cost and an immature design more persuasive explanations than a completed aircraft rejected in trials.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
The Strait of Hormuz became easier to close and easier to reopen
Mines, missiles, coastal weapons, and fortified terrain strengthen denial, while aircraft, long-range strike, and land attack strengthen the force trying to suppress them.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A floatplane Albacore would scout for battleships and cruisers
The design arrived after shipborne floatplanes were losing favor, but its intended work resembled the reconnaissance role of Swordfish floatplanes.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A mined Hormuz would put minehunters under carrier cover
In the June 2025 scenario, nearby Royal Navy mine-countermeasure forces would clear the route while a carrier group protected them from interference.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
A Crown Colony-sized Dido needs fewer heavy mounts and more light AA
Six twin 5.25-inch mounts with strong pom-pom batteries would make a durable fleet escort, while eight twins would impose excessive topweight and hull stress.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Crown Colony cruisers belong with the battle fleet
A larger Crown Colony class would mostly screen carriers and capital ships in the Home and Mediterranean fleets rather than disperse to foreign stations.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Royal Navy support at the Battle of Gabon
British ships supplied logistics, naval gunfire, and anti-submarine support to a campaign whose decisive work remained ashore.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Interwar Italian warships served deep into the Cold War
Several Regia Marina ships continued under the postwar Marina Militare, with Giuseppe Garibaldi surviving in service until 1971.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Insufficient testing caused early-war torpedo failures
Torpedo defects persisted because navies underfunded testing and failed to test weapons realistically across enough operating conditions.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Revealing Yamato's 18-inch guns changes US deployment
If Japan publicly revealed Yamato's 18-inch guns at Pearl Harbor, political and operational pressure would send America's newest battleships to the Pacific.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·
Britain estimated Yamato's guns from photographs
British analysts used a grainy photograph to estimate Yamato's main battery at roughly 17 inches, allowing about an inch of uncertainty.
From Bruships 198: Naval History Questions Answered Live... ·