Q&A · 1:22:39 Modernizing HMS Unicorn would yield an air group comparable to other light fleet carriers, with limited room for early jets and helicopters.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 1:23:49 The F6F Hellcat is the personal choice, while the answer distinguishes that preference from a settled ranking of every Second World War fighter.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 1:29:00 MAC ships show how wartime requirements were reduced and adapted to the limits of available merchant yards.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 1:34:37 A production-design book shows how Colonial and Cylon spacecraft changed across the original series, the reimagining, and Blood & Chrome.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 1:38:34 Adding a sixth turret to a Moltke-class battlecruiser increases weight and threatens speed without solving the compromises of the existing wing-turret layout.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 1:41:14 The larger three-crew Cylon Raider is interpreted as a long-range strike aircraft, while the Viper fills the compact air-defence fighter role.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 1:42:10 A question on Romania's Gowind corvettes becomes a case for distinct high-end, general-purpose, and forward-presence roles.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 1:46:10 The aft turret sits above a cut-down stern rather than unusually high above the rest of Moltke's main battery.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 1:47:10 The 11-inch armament is presented as an industrial constraint, not simply a diplomatic gesture to Britain and France.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 1:48:58 Construction drawings and carpentry details change how viewers see the cost and complexity of sail-era fleets.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 1:51:28 Plans of the Conte di Cavour and Duilio classes show how extensive reconstruction and ammunition stowage shaped their wartime form.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 1:56:51 The jump from 305 mm to 320 mm guns offered a useful capability gain without an unacceptable stowage penalty.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 2:01:15 An illustrated cutaway book is recommended as an accessible route from age-of-sail warships to ironclads and modern destroyers.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 2:03:41 A notional fleet of 12 ships in each escort category provides predictable operational, transit, and refit capacity.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 2:04:38 The planned Sea Ceptor addition discussed in 2021 would improve Type 45, although Mark 41 offered broader flexibility.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 2:09:26 A Star Trek discussion argues that fleet design needs numerous smaller combatants and expendable sensors, not only large cruisers.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:25:12 Type 23 frigates will be old when Type 26 replaces them, but Chile or another established operator might still buy a hull for service or spares.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:25:29 A 12-gun, 16-inch Conqueror-style ship would change the Denmark Strait balance through heavier salvo weight and similar speed.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:31:43 StanFlex separates the modular payload from the ship's standard sensor fit, with the module integrated into the host platform.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:33:53 A shell bursting outside a ship can damage radar and other exposed equipment, but it does less to the hull than a direct hit.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:36:06 A one-on-one fight is plausible, but Prince of Wales entered the Denmark Strait action before her turrets and guns were fully reliable.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:37:00 If Hood and Bismarck sank each other, Britain would mourn a hero but accept the one-for-one strategic exchange and likely reuse Hood's name quickly.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:37:57 A Rodney-Bismarck duel depends on manoeuvre and target aspect, not a static broadside comparison dominated by freeboard.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:43:35 Fictional warships operating alone in space need their own strike craft, self-defence, repair capacity, and missile production.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 2:47:14 The fictional battlestar's ring of eight engines creates a concentrated vulnerability despite its otherwise capable carrier features.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:49:29 A fully preserved Grand Fleet would need museum berths spread among Liverpool, Welsh and Scottish dockyards, the Medway, and Plymouth.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:49:50 Warp, hyperdrive, and wormhole travel are compared as speculative ideas, with an explicit warning that none is presented here as settled physics.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:51:33 Limited building capacity makes reserve ships attractive, although a meaningful expansion is considered unlikely.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 2:51:57 A Star Trek design question compares rounded Starfleet hulls with Borg spheres and cubes through speculative warp-field efficiency and internal volume.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 2:53:15 Britain's post-1945 naval contraction is framed as a set of competing spending and policy decisions rather than a single story of national insolvency.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:02:07 Health-service design and the pace of debt repayment are presented as choices within severe postwar constraints, not automatic consequences of the war.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:05:40 Warspite's severe damage prevented a reserve career that might have carried her into the museum-ship era, unlike a hypothetical Hood-named Vanguard.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:08:22 Ration books protected access to scarce goods, while wartime employment and wages helped lower-income households use that entitlement.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:09:14 A short answer attributes limited close-in weapon fits to procurement cost rather than a lack of defensive value.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:16:27 Modern machinery offers much better power density and lower manning, but a deep battleship conversion would still be difficult and expensive.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:17:02 A much larger share of GDP for defence would produce a Royal Navy several times larger, but also more capable and expensive individual ships.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:22:16 A defecting Bismarck would be valuable, but the Royal Navy would rapidly replace or supervise much of its crew before trusting it in sensitive waters.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:28:48 The 1783 HMS Thunderer, a Trafalgar veteran later altered to an 84-gun ship, is selected as a favourite 74.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:31:11 US cruiser secondary batteries worked, but multiple gun types and ammunition streams complicate supply and operations.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:33:00 Simple bankruptcy language is treated as a later explanatory frame that can hide policy choices made during the 1960s and 1970s.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 3:37:31 M. J. Whitley's destroyer survey is recommended for its photographs, drawings, statistics, and cross-navy coverage.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Chapter · 3:40:28 Wings of the Navy uses one test pilot's consistent judgement to show how a conservative biplane successor lost the qualities that kept Swordfish useful.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:46:50 Postwar emergency-destroyer conversions offered roughly twenty years of useful frigate service, while the proposed Type 62 would likely have followed a similar pattern.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 3:47:40 Information from an anti-Nazi enemy intelligence chief still required verification, and the surviving record does not reveal every warning or its effect.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Notable Point · 3:59:11 Wartime slogans can obscure the British Empire, European allies, rearmament timing, and the international finance that sustained Britain's war effort.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 4:05:02 The cruiser label has declined partly through its association with empire, while increasingly large destroyers continue many cruiser functions.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 4:05:37 A proposed Unicorn modernization would likely replace much of the original battery with 40 mm weapons and perhaps an early missile system.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021
Q&A · 4:06:19 An OPV needing an arsenal ship has already been placed in the wrong threat environment; the money is usually better spent on frigates.
From Bruships 61 - Ship Design; Sci-fi, Wooden & Steel, and some Naval History Questions · 21 Nov 2021