Nimrod, Comet and the square-window problem
Maintenance and changes to square window frames are offered as the explanation for addressing Comet-related structural problems.
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
British yards as a source of interwar Baltic submarines
Britain's many submarine-building yards could have supplied several boats in an interwar Baltic procurement counterfactual.
Balancing present capability with future growth margin
Long-lived warships need useful capability on delivery as well as reserved space for upgrades that cannot yet be specified.
What 3,000 extra tons could do for Nelson
Applying the carrier-conversion tonnage allowance to Nelson is legally doubtful, but it highlights how more displacement could buy speed or a fourth turret.
Examples of warships with room for later changes
Renown and Danish modular frigates are offered as examples of ships that accommodated later improvements.
Were pyramid stones quarried or poured?
Quarrying remains the preferred explanation for pyramid stones.
Why archaeology works best beside written sources
Artifacts become more informative when dated written sources can guide interpretation, test identities, and expose uncertainty about names, titles, and peoples.
A more capable Fearless and Intrepid
More hangar and command space plus a modest gun fit could strengthen the assault ships without turning them into Albion-sized vessels.
A Harry Bennett naval-history reading guide
A compact tour of Harry Bennett's books points readers toward Royal Navy policy, Bismarck and Tirpitz, disguised raiders, naval aviation, and German admirals.
Why large naval guns rarely use muzzle brakes
Longer barrels and a different operating environment are offered as reasons naval guns can dispense with muzzle brakes.
Lost libraries at Carthage and in East Asia
Besides Alexandria, lost collections at Carthage and in East Asia could have preserved richer accounts of regional history and Zheng He's voyages.
Atlantis as a composite flood tradition
Atlantis is treated as uncertain, with memories of flooded coastal cities suggested as one possible origin for the legend.
The Four Courts fire and Irish record loss
The recalled Four Courts record loss is judged especially damaging to Irish history, with less effect on wider European and world history.
HMS London across cruiser service and imperial retreat
Ian Ballantyne's HMS London connects the County-class cruiser's refits and wartime operations with earlier and later ships carrying the same name.
HMS London, QP15 and the pressure of Arctic convoy service
London's convoy screening duties continued under German fleet pressure while the cruiser urgently needed repairs.
What records survived the Great Fire of London
The Great Fire destroyed records, but Britain's leading scholarly collections at Oxford, Cambridge, and York Minster lay outside the burned area.
The maintenance burden of three carrier aircraft types
Operating three distinct aircraft types would create a substantial maintenance and supply burden aboard a British carrier.
P.1154 fighters would still need airborne early warning
A P.1154-equipped task force would still face the Falklands early-warning gap.
Aircraft spares make the supply ship a carrier-group vulnerability
Extra storage aboard a larger carrier would not eliminate the spare-parts burden or dependence on its supply ship.
An early British ballistic-missile submarine force
A functioning British sea-based nuclear deterrent by 1957 would require nuclear submarines and could make Britain a technology supplier to the United States.
Argentina's neighboring states in an alternative-war scenario
An alternative-war hypothetical compares Uruguay and other neighbors while finding no easy military target.
Why a carrier needs both fighters and a strike aircraft
The preference for retaining the A-6 Intruder rests on strike range and payload, while replacing Phantoms with Hornets is easier to justify.
A post-Falklands British 70,000-ton carrier air wing
A large British carrier ordered after the Falklands would likely mix Tomcats, a renewed Buccaneer strike aircraft, Hawkeye early warning, and perhaps S-3 Vikings.
Two Tomcats against a formation of Zeros
A Tomcat-versus-Zero hypothetical turns on undetected missile attacks and a finite missile supply.
Why the salvage ship Kommuna remained useful
Kommuna remained useful because its twin-hull salvage function still worked and the ship saw little use.
Why the York class looked like cut-price Counties
Exeter's name and crew are admired, but the smaller design is judged an unattractive economy unless the saving buys more ships.
Sea Fury and Swordfish as Fleet Air Arm favorites
The preferred Fleet Air Arm aircraft narrows to the Hawker Sea Fury and Fairey Swordfish rather than the proposed Albacore.
Launching and recovering a Tomcat with six Phoenix missiles
The six-Phoenix hypothetical distinguishes what a Tomcat might launch with from what it could recover aboard carrying.
Finding Royal Navy history of the Korean War
With the Carriers in Korea is suggested for American and Royal Navy carrier operations, with a qualification that the book had not been read recently.
Missile capacity against a World War II fighter swarm
A hypothetical contest against World War II fighters initially favors a heavily armed F-15, before proposed bomber-sized missile loads shift the preference.
Damage tolerance does not make an A-10 shellproof
The A-10 comparison distinguishes surviving damage from immunity to 23 mm fire.
A November 2022 assessment of Ukrainian advances and Russian escalation
A November 2022 assessment favors further Ukrainian advances while acknowledging Russian nuclear risk and uncertainty about a successor leadership.
The Falklands War backfired on Argentina's leadership
The Falklands War illustrates how an external conflict could damage Argentina and its military leadership.
Mediterranean Fleet planning before the Second World War
A documentary collection opens a window onto Royal Navy planning during the Abyssinian crisis, Spanish Civil War, and approach to war.
Why Pound preferred convoy protection to Scheme Z
Pound's 1937 criticism of Scheme Z connects submarine detection to air coverage and the convoy system's immediate counterattack advantage.
Keeping twelve destroyers on patrol required a larger force
A plan for twelve destroyers continuously on patrol required reliefs, maintenance cover, and additional Home Fleet ships.
Scheme Z relied on uncertain morale effects
Pound distinguishes killing submarines from intimidating their crews, then judges Scheme Z too dependent on luck.
Using document collections before visiting the archives
Printed document collections support initial research and writing while leaving a role for checking the complete archival originals.
Why destroyer development advances in waves
Destroyer innovation accumulates across many ships and then jumps when a larger design becomes affordable at fleet scale.
Why a capital ship's deterrent value matters
A capital ship represents national power, so conspicuous economies can weaken its deterrent effect.
The Revenge class and the danger of cut-price capital ships
The Revenge class accepted lower speed, but its planned eight-ship scale and retained 15-inch armament partly compensated for the compromise.
How a 28-knot battle line enlarges its battlecruisers
A fast, twelve-gun Queen Elizabeth counterfactual drives larger battlecruisers and suggests a nine-gun Revenge as the cheaper alternative.
Triple-turret Renowns need more machinery space
A 28-knot starting design could become a faster Renown by adding hull length and machinery while retaining three triple turrets.
Fast Queen Elizabeths set the speed of later battleships
A 28-knot British battle line raises the minimum speed for Nelson and King George V and pushes the battlecruisers faster still.
Why speeding up the Revenge class was expensive
Limited machinery space made higher-speed Revenge refits more expensive than the proposed boiler change suggests.
Why Alaska fits the cruiser lineage
Treaty definitions based on the Hawkins class interrupted the older hierarchy of cruisers and help explain the argument for treating Alaska as a large cruiser.
Would faster Renowns replace the Admiral class?
A 32-knot Renown makes more of the same attractive, but leaves an incentive to build an even faster Admiral.
An American response to Britain's faster capital ships
The expected American response combines heavier armament with somewhat lower speed, potentially using twelve 16-inch guns.