Video

The Romans are counter attack, the Numidians are coming for me, can we stabilise it?

Study The Romans are counter attack, the Numidians are coming for me, can we stabilise it?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 15 May 2023, with 22 time notes. Topics include Battle of the Atlantic, Carthage, Historical…

Date
Runtime2:49:34
Guide points22 time notes

Time notes

  1. 4:35
    Why the campaign makes Italy an economic objective

    The Carthage campaign makes Italy an economic objective because control of Mediterranean trade routes funds continued expansion.

    Chapter
  2. 13:46
    Securing North Africa while the main war is in Italy

    A target-of-opportunity decision shows the tension between pursuing the principal enemy and stabilizing a vulnerable home region.

    Notable Point
  3. 16:43
    What an archer-free Carthaginian roster leaves out

    The game's archer-free Carthaginian roster conflicts with the claim that Carthage fielded some of the ancient Mediterranean's best archers.

    Notable Point
  4. 22:40
    Holding Rome consumes the manoeuvre force

    The army protecting Rome leaves Carthage without a mobile force for other emergencies.

    Notable Point
  5. 26:12
    Why a carrier catapult faces a different test

    A comparison between German mail-ship catapults and carrier aviation shows why equipment that works at sea in peacetime may fail under combat sortie rates.

    Notable Point
  6. 29:02
    Remembering a campaign that had no single day

    Battle of the Atlantic commemoration raises the problem of representing a long maritime campaign through one symbolic date.

    Notable Point
  7. 30:43
    Why interwar air-power arguments missed naval needs

    An interwar discussion explains how assumptions about geography and threats shaped British arguments over naval aviation and funding.

    Chapter
  8. 34:40
    The imperial geography behind a British sea-control assumption

    British planners could treat the Indian Ocean as comparatively secure only because they assumed control of key imperial gateways and bases.

    Notable Point
  9. 38:41
    War turns a trade road into lost revenue

    The campaign makes the economic cost of war visible when a promising road fails to produce income from hostile neighbors.

    Notable Point
  10. 41:00
    Why one ship should not seal a defended port

    A blockade rule lets one hostile ship close a port while an entire friendly fleet remains inside.

    Notable Point
  11. 43:50
    Terrain and a cavalry sweep against a Numidian army

    A field battle turns on recognizing the useful rise, organizing a large cavalry wing, and exploiting the opponent's poor deployment.

    Chapter
  12. 59:47
    Defending Sicily before the battle reaches the walls

    A comparison of infantry, cavalry, and skirmishers supports fighting in the field before a more difficult siege develops.

    Notable Point
  13. 1:03:57
    High ground matters only if the flanks and retreat route work

    The Roman deployment gives up favorable terrain, loses control of its flanks, and retreats into ground that exposes it to a downhill attack.

    Chapter
  14. 1:10:30
    Strong Roman infantry collapses after a rear attack

    A second engagement demonstrates how solid heavy infantry can be undone by cavalry reaching its rear and closing its escape route.

    Notable Point
  15. 1:34:42
    Four-to-one cavalry superiority breaks the Numidian siege

    A siege breakout shows why even spearmen struggle when cavalry outnumbers them four to one.

    Notable Point
  16. 1:52:55
    QuestionWould Graf Zeppelin have been decisive if Germany had put the carrier to sea?Answer

    It could create problems, but any claim that it would be decisive has to account for how Britain would respond to the new threat.

    Q&A
  17. 1:57:09
    Taking Rome creates a larger consolidation problem

    After capturing Rome, the campaign shifts from opportunity to consolidation as Roman factions, trade, armies, and fleet requirements compete for attention.

    Chapter
  18. 2:01:51
    Economic recovery makes a Capua advance possible

    Recent territorial gains strengthen the economy enough to consider taking Capua as a mutually supporting position for Rome.

    Notable Point
  19. 2:03:24
    Concentrating three armies before accepting battle

    Concentrating complementary armies, choosing a night attack, and taking favorable ground changes the balance before battle.

    Notable Point
  20. 2:29:02
    A Soviet battle-fleet programme would reshape rearmament

    The consequences of Stalin's planned fleet depend on when and which version of the programme becomes real.

    Notable Point
  21. 2:34:52
    Using high ground and reinforcements to reach the enemy general

    Reinforcements arriving behind the Carthaginian line and a cavalry route through the Roman archers create an opportunity to kill the opposing commander.

    Chapter
  22. 2:46:41
    Why Capua comes before the remaining 41 regions

    The next phase reinforces Rome, takes Capua, and pushes north under a victory condition that still demands 41 regions.

    Notable Point