Video
Cruiser Submarine: Crackpot Schemes or Good Ideas Badly Done p5/7
Study Cruiser Submarine: Crackpot Schemes or Good Ideas Badly Done p5/7, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 12 Aug 2021, with 10 time notes. Topics include Commerce Raiding, Convoy Warfare, Cruiser Submarines.
Time notes
- 0:19Why gun-armed cruiser submarines appealed in the 1920sChapter
Smaller, cheaper shells made a gun attractive aboard a submarine intended for long-range commerce raiding and shore bombardment.
- 3:21Convoys undercut gun-armed raidersNotable Point
Convoys exposed a surfaced gun-armed submarine to escort fire, while its low position in the water limited range finding.
- 4:20A cruiser submarine's odds against escort gunsChapter
Rough first-hit estimates favour a corvette over a cruiser submarine, while a worked-up destroyer's multiple gun mounts offer a much stronger advantage.
- 5:49Why a larger gun did not guarantee a longer engagement rangeNotable Point
Low lookouts limited how far a submarine could see, allowing taller escorts to use their guns at comparable or greater practical ranges.
- 6:28Gun-mount weight and waterproofingNotable Point
Large topside guns added drag and weight; storing their ammunition above or inside the hull created different risks when diving.
- 8:04A long-range raider with six or more forward torpedo tubesChapter
A proposed long-range raider would carry six or more forward torpedo tubes and two to three reloads per tube for operations far from its base.
- 10:10The case for ending cruiser-submarine gun experiments soonerNotable Point
British and other navies' work on minelayers and larger submarines offered alternatives to prolonged development of the gun-armed cruiser submarine.
- 11:04A larger T-class submarine as the alternativeChapter
A proposed larger T-class submarine would combine a stronger hull, greater diving depth and longer range with enough torpedoes to fulfil the cruiser-submarine role.
- 11:46Torpedoes and mines could confuse a raider's pursuersNotable Point
Torpedo attacks and delayed mine strikes at different positions could disguise a submarine's route and disrupt shipping along whole coastlines.
- 12:31Long-range submarines, distant bases and the cost of surfacingChapter
Germany's shortage of long-range boats and Britain's reliance on overseas bases introduce the danger of taking surface damage far from support.