Video
85% is still a First! The Queen Elizabeth Class Aircraft Carriers...
Study 85% is still a First! The Queen Elizabeth Class Aircraft Carriers..., a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 26 Nov 2024, with 33 time notes. Topics include Airborne Early Warning, Aircraft Carriers, British Defence Policy.
Time notes
- 2:22Why mobile airfields still matterChapter
Crewed and uncrewed aircraft both need weapons and maintenance, preserving the carrier's role as a mobile aviation base.
- 3:36Libya and the limits of distant air supportNotable Point
Libya illustrates the difference between delivering a distant strike and sustaining aircraft over troops or a naval force.
- 4:31Fighters and missiles in layered air defenceNotable Point
Treating interceptor aircraft and surface-to-air missiles as rival budget choices removes capabilities that a layered defence needs together.
- 7:32Why carrier tonnage alone cannot compare fleet optionsNotable Point
Dividing total carrier tonnage among three hulls repeats machinery costs and can reduce combined aircraft capacity.
- 8:34Why two carriers cannot guarantee certaintyNotable Point
Commercial fleet models can forecast contracts and hire extra vehicles; carrier procurement must allow for crises that cannot be scheduled or met with hired ships.
- 13:20CVA-01 and the politics of inter-service compromiseChapter
Protected RAF programmes and the memory of CVA-01 encouraged inter-service compromise around the new carrier programme.
- 18:01Why Britain chose the F-35B and STOVL carriersChapter
The F-35B offered a distinct role alongside RAF jets and a way to operate from both large carriers and future amphibious ships.
- 18:33How the RAF's two-fast-jet model shaped carrier aviationNotable Point
The RAF's preference for overlapping fast-jet generations, together with the prospect of parallel Wedgetail and Hawkeye fleets, helped make F-35C and CATOBAR politically difficult choices.
- 27:06How dry docks constrained carrier sizeChapter
British dry-dock sizes and conditions constrained carrier dimensions and the number of facilities available for construction and maintenance.
- 30:35Distributed block construction as industrial policyChapter
The carrier alliance spread modules among British yards to accelerate work, distribute skills and spending, and avoid a single yard's temporary labour surge.
- 31:44Larger dry docks and a longer carrierNotable Point
A proposed investment in larger British dry docks would have supported a longer carrier and commercial shipping, with overseas docks available as backups.
- 35:05Crowsnest, Hawkeye, and the 70-80 percent solutionNotable Point
Helicopter-borne Crowsnest is less capable than Hawkeye, but it can deploy from more ships and draws on British industry.
- 38:23Carrier dimensions and dry-dock fitChapter
Published hull dimensions explain how the carrier's broad flight deck can overhang a dock that accommodates its narrower hull.
- 39:39Propulsion redundancy and shaft riskNotable Point
Debates over an additional gas turbine, common diesel engines, and a third shaft show the redundancy and maintenance choices behind the carriers' propulsion.
- 42:17Carrier sensors, fitted weapons, and aircraft capacityNotable Point
S1850M and Artisan radars support the carrier's defences, with Phalanx and machine guns fitted, provision for four DS30M guns, and a qualified estimate of aircraft capacity.
- 46:39RFA helicopters and global carrier operationsNotable Point
Auxiliary ships with large hangars can share the group's Merlin helicopter work, provided enough ships and aircraft are available.
- 48:47How extra length changes hangar capacityNotable Point
A rough hangar-layout calculation shows why extra length could add more F-35Bs than a small increase in beam.
- 51:28The infrastructure cost of nuclear carrier propulsionNotable Point
Nuclear propulsion would require a surface-ship reactor programme, supporting facilities and training, while restricting access to some countries.
- 52:49The 2010 CATOBAR reversal and carrier-strike gapChapter
Reopening the CATOBAR decision in 2010 promised cheaper interim aircraft but threatened a third fast-jet fleet and exposed the risk of retiring Harrier early.
- 54:53Carriers for a European and global BritainChapter
Mobile carrier forces can serve Britain's global trade interests, European security, and NATO reinforcement routes.
- 59:11F-35B numbers and the Joint Force conceptChapter
Delayed F-35B purchases left the carriers short of aircraft, although STOVL made a joint Navy-RAF surge force easier to qualify for deck operations.
- 1:01:29Defence spending as national insuranceNotable Point
An insurance analogy explains defence budgets as choices about acceptable national risk, with the Falklands showing how consequences outlast the ministers who make cuts.
- 1:05:39The escort shortage around the carriersChapter
Declining destroyer and frigate numbers leave carrier groups short of escorts, despite the growing capability of individual ships.
- 1:07:59Carriers as diplomatic signalsNotable Point
Frequent crises and diplomatic deployments pushed Britain to keep both carriers active more often than the original one-active, one-refitting model expected.
- 1:10:17The allied carrier networkChapter
British, French, and American carrier forces share coverage and escorts, while wider cooperation links Britain with Japan and Australia.
- 1:16:13F-35B cross-decking across allied shipsNotable Point
Different allied flight decks could exchange aircraft and support one another if each can operate the F-35B.
- 1:17:01Future carrier aircraft and electronic warfareNotable Point
Future uncrewed aircraft must withstand electronic warfare, while the form and timing of the F-35B's successor remain uncertain.
- 1:19:50Why long-range uncrewed aircraft need onboard computingChapter
Payload, onboard computing, and limited communications capacity constrain the size and operation of future uncrewed carrier aircraft.
- 1:21:18Uncrewed early warning and command personnelNotable Point
An uncrewed radar aircraft would move command work back into the carrier group, with consequences for where people and equipment are needed.
- 1:22:52The 85-percent value testChapter
The value of a carrier design depends on affordable compromises, existing infrastructure, and enough supporting capability to make the whole force useful.
- 1:24:35Why diplomacy still needs material powerNotable Point
International politics lacks a neutral enforcement system, so diplomacy and shared rules still depend on credible power.
- 1:27:03Future escort design and affordable numbersNotable Point
A viewer discussion prompt applies the problem of affordable capability and fleet numbers to future large surface escorts.
- 1:29:15Rosyth assembly and the cost of delayNotable Point
Dock access, Scottish shipbuilding commitments, and construction delays shaped the carrier programme and its eventual cost.