Q&A · 44:27 A Bismarck counterfactual asks what happens if all four major German capital ships sail together, prompting a much larger British carrier-and-battleship response.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 48:20 Radio-message volume could reveal German naval activity before messages were decoded, complementing cruiser and aircraft surveillance.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 51:27 A second sortie variant sends Scharnhorst and Gneisenau from France while Bismarck and Tirpitz sail from the north, producing two British carrier-backed interception forces.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 58:59 The recorded state of H and J shows why contracts, ordered material, and a nominally large yard did not equal a battleship close to completion.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:01:49 Large-engine manufacture faced limits in production speed, quality control, metallurgy and access to materials.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:02:20 Enlarging a gun bore changes barrel proportions and liner durability, even when the ammunition hoist can be modified.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:03:28 A proposed diesel installation changes the historical design and has to be assessed as an alternative development programme.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:04:29 Features that might accommodate automatic loading do not establish that the relevant loading system was being developed.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:05:05 The choice of domestic 11-inch armament combined a political preference with the weapons actually available.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:05:30 Earlier German capital ships provide a construction-time baseline for assessing the proposed H-class completion schedule.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:10:09 Scharnhorst and Gneisenau illustrate why clearing a slipway early could increase the work remaining after launch.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:11:44 A larger yard programme required experienced workers and industrial support, with costs for other ships competing for the same resources.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:15:20 A proposed electric-drive advantage brings testing, crew-training and manufacturing demands into the H-class construction schedule.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:19:25 An H-class propulsion objection separates construction time from the efficiency and response of a period electric-drive installation.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:22:35 Alternative diesels would add development risk to a battleship programme already constrained by workers, factory output and competing demands.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:25:31 A hypothetical 40,000-ton treaty limit allows a different combination of British battleship speed, armour and armament.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Q&A · 1:32:54 The Kate's folding wings correct a blanket claim about Japanese aircraft, while fighter design exposes different performance and material choices.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:35:11 Mediterranean and South China Sea airfields explain why British carriers needed protection even when their own fighters were available.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:37:09 Japanese fighter development and Britain's 4.7-inch destroyer gun illustrate how exercises and limited combat experience can validate unsuitable choices.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 1:39:39 A viewer's objection to a comic Town-class scenario prompts brief recollections of German admirals' pessimistic expectations.
From Scuttlebutt 2: H Class Battleships, Japanese Carrier Aircraft Design and lots more · 5 Jun 2024
Chapter · 0:26 Shokaku, Implacable, and Essex reveal what their navies wanted once treaty limits began to disappear.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 0:45 Churchill's capital-ship pause is criticised alongside an alleged politically driven reclassification of Scharnhorst and Gneisenau.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Chapter · 6:40 A forward island, 34.5-knot speed, and 72 operational aircraft show how Shokaku supported fast carrier strikes.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 8:04 Japan expected to weaken an advancing enemy through attrition and ambush before committing its main fleet.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 11:23 The Pearl Harbor force combined older carriers, treaty-era designs, and the two new Shokaku-class ships.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 13:09 Shokaku added guns, protection, and aircraft while slightly exceeding Hiryu's speed.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 15:21 Yamato absorbed resources while Japan relied on two preferred fleet carriers and slower emergency conversions.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 18:00 Sinking an enemy carrier favored a large opening strike, while British operating areas also demanded continuous air cover and repeated sorties.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Chapter · 20:57 Implacable brought the large strike air group and protected fleet-carrier role together in one British design.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 23:23 The quoted specifications show an armored British carrier carrying 81 operational aircraft at 32.5 knots.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 25:31 Larger aircraft and the end of cumulative treaty limits explain carrier growth and Britain's demand for both protection and a large air group.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Chapter · 30:20 Implacable's range makes sense inside a British system of global bases, fuel stocks, convoys, and fast fleet oilers.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 31:06 Fuel investment continued despite the Ten Year Rule, while a private-paper anecdote illustrates the scale of naval ambitions and its evidential limits.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 34:26 Pauses and repeated wartime changes pushed Implacable and Indefatigable from a possible 1942 entry into service to 1944.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 36:03 Far Eastern commitments gave the Air Ministry a wartime reason to support naval carriers and preserve aircraft for North Africa.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 38:14 British design compromises are compared with the coercive political conditions that limited resistance to naval preferences in interwar Japan.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 39:11 Tentative fighter, scout-fighter, and strike-aircraft plans show how the carrier and its air group were expected to develop together.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 41:06 High beacons and illuminated floats helped returning aircraft find and approach the carrier at night.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 41:53 The heavy and light anti-aircraft batteries are clear, while the exact Oerlikon allocation remains uncertain.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Chapter · 43:42 Essex developed a familiar carrier design so American yards could reproduce the capabilities the Navy wanted in large numbers.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 44:39 Essex carried belt and deck protection, with STS contributing to survival after damage.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 46:32 The preserved Essex carriers show later rebuilds, while a role-based definition of modernity reaches back to Lexington.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 48:46 Essex, Implacable, and Shokaku are judged by the navy and theater each was designed to serve.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Chapter · 50:27 A tall hangar, deck-edge lift, and air group of up to 100 aircraft supported the American deck-load strike.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 52:38 Essex's quoted 20,000-nautical-mile range served a campaign with different supply requirements from British and Japanese plans.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 53:58 Pearl Harbor is interpreted as an attempt to provoke an American advance before mass-produced Essex carriers made Japanese attrition strategy untenable.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 56:33 Raids, early carrier losses, and HMS Victorious's service with Saratoga explain the interval before the Essex buildup.
From Carriers of the Planned War Fleets: How Shokaku, Implacables & Essexs reflect their Navys Doctrines · 4 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 11:22 The opening action shows how torpedo avoidance, target discipline, and four supporting battleships outweigh a French capital ship's paper gun advantage.
From Check Campaign 19: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign · 3 Jun 2024