Q&A · 2:04:27 Leadership and discipline could transfer from land command while sailing masters supplied specialist shiphandling knowledge.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:05:57 Montanas would replace older Standard-type battleships in the heavy line and free Iowas for screening and pursuit.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:06:54 Operational role and naval-architecture criteria lead to different ways of classifying a fast capital ship.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:08:31 Improving power density reduced the armor and subdivision sacrificed to give a capital ship greater speed.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:09:31 The fast capital ships needed to support a cruiser line already reaching roughly 32 knots.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:11:01 The Independence conversions show how hull space, emergency timing, and a carrier's real defensive needs outweighed the appeal of adding a single larger gun.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:14:19 Roman naval power faced its strongest external test in the Punic Wars and later served the rival forces in the civil wars.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 2:14:33 Weight, hull space, and mounting availability are suggested as possible explanations for the single gun.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:16:26 Limited money explains the Dutch choice of a small protected-cruiser program without armored cruisers.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:16:39 A full Lexington or Saratoga air group could sink Bismarck, but Victorious faced shortages of aircraft and trained reconnaissance crews.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:19:30 The ships were capable and suited to Dutch needs, but national finances limited how many could be built while land defences also demanded funding.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:20:49 A handful of modern escorts would be overwhelmed if isolated near Korea in 1941, but the same ships could add useful strength inside an Allied campaign.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:23:16 A delayed war could let Hood enter her planned reconstruction after Renown and return as a more capable capital ship.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 2:24:09 Extra construction time benefits Britain and France as well as Germany, leaving Plan Z behind larger Allied programs rather than delivering naval parity.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:27:36 Forward bases, usable patrol endurance, fuel reserves, and mined entrances limited submarine operations in the Sea of Japan.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:28:41 A surviving Ark Royal is expected to join Force Z and strengthen ABDA, changing the Southeast Asian campaign before Midway.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 2:32:21 A transposed position report is blamed for sending Somerville's night strike toward the wrong location during Operation C.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:33:41 Their range and surface speed support a broad cruiser-submarine label, while their exposed 6-inch guns served quicker attacks on targets.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:34:27 Welders, electrical installation, and complex plumbing add production constraints beyond the availability of money, reactors, and yards.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:37:10 Henderson traded his eighteen-ship L70 destroyer proposal for carrier orders; the design later returned, updated, as the Daring class.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:39:15 Restoring the Third Sea Lord title is proposed as a way to strengthen the Controller's standing when advocating for the Navy.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:42:06 A more accurate Jutland account and different carrier policies are weighed against losing Beatty's strength as a treaty negotiator.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:46:02 Continued naval control could accelerate engine development and encourage larger carrier aircraft after experience exposed practical air-group limits.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:49:52 Greater hangar height alone would not lead Britain to copy American overhead stowage of spare aircraft.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 2:50:45 An earlier Supermarine naval-fighter proposal is compared with the later Seafire conversion in visibility, deck space, and intended role.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Chapter · 2:58:17 An alternate Washington Conference scheme uses Dominion prestige and treaty arithmetic to create a special class of 20,000-ton, 12-inch-gunned large cruisers.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Chapter · 3:04:25 Steve Clark's alternate-history essay converts Francesco Caracciolo into a carrier with an uninterrupted flight deck in response to French naval aviation.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Chapter · 3:08:49 An alternate-history essay presents a secretly completed Amagi as an interwar intelligence dossier built from letters, annotations, and scattered clues.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:18:37 Nuclear certification, dock dimensions, and lifelong maintenance access narrow the number of facilities that can build and support a carrier.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 3:22:15 A much larger carrier proposal meets the cost and geography of rebuilding the docks needed throughout its service life.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:25:01 A three-navy Jutland could spread the Royal Navy's frustration over the German night escape into American and Japanese interwar doctrine.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:29:58 American battleship reinforcements raise questions about fuel choice, gunnery practice, speed, and propellant temperature.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:34:35 Tiger's survival after comparable hits supports the explanation that Queen Mary's ammunition-handling procedures made the damage catastrophic.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:35:54 Baltic reinforcement landings and brief Pacific raids are considered more plausible than a major opposed invasion of Russia.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 3:37:50 The November 2024 assessment distinguishes Black Sea failures from the missile capability and condition of other Russian fleet units.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:44:05 Removing Argentina's French-built corvettes, British-built guided-missile destroyers, and light carrier changes the political decision before it changes a battle.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:44:28 Four Queen Elizabeths per Dominion could overturn the postwar balance and prevent the Washington building holiday.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 3:49:28 The expanded Dominion fleets would put pressure on Britain's own battle line and feed a cycle of larger American, British, and Japanese designs.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 3:53:12 A 55,000-ton game battlecruiser prompts criticism of wing turrets and command spaces, with its likely speed reconsidered during the exchange.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 3:58:06 Togo's standing at home and abroad gives this counterfactual a possible route toward moderation, while success remains a long shot.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:02:01 Night operations could worsen the opening attack, while a stronger replacement-pilot pipeline would sustain Japanese carrier strength for longer.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:05:11 Fast replenishment is proposed to support high-speed gas-turbine escorts, while LCS provides local protection through confined approaches.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 4:09:17 A proposed return to nuclear cruisers leads into electrical-power conversion and the difficulty of creating another suitable building yard.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 4:13:00 A case for public ownership links specialized naval yards' sole-customer position to contract profits and financing costs.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:18:44 An earlier battlecruiser specification could yield roughly 35,000-ton ships with eight 15-inch guns on the Revenge-class timetable.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:20:49 Italian torpedo-cruiser construction reflected rivalry with France and a live doctrinal contest between expensive battleships and numerous smaller torpedo craft.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:22:34 Sloops performed useful but routine duties, while navies sent cruisers into the dangerous operations most likely to produce headlines and later histories.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024
Q&A · 4:23:50 Two ironclads appearing at Athens in 1452 could intervene at Constantinople, using protected naval gunfire and marines behind the walls.
From Jellicoe as 3rd Sea Lord, Essay Competion & WoW Collab: Last 9 of the 36hr Historiophon Part 4/4 · 24 Nov 2024