Q&A · 3:44:28-3:49:28

Four Queen Elizabeths for each Dominion and the treaty balance

Four Queen Elizabeths per Dominion could overturn the postwar balance and prevent the Washington building holiday.

Question

What if each Dominion received four additional Queen Elizabeth-class battleships?

Short answer

The much larger imperial battle line could provoke American modernization and prevent a Washington-style building holiday.

Notes

The premise gives each Dominion four Queen Elizabeth-class battleships, producing an imperial total discussed as twenty to twenty-five ships of that class. Such a concentration of fast 15-inch battleships would make the postwar naval balance much harder to settle. A Washington-style building holiday is rejected in favor of a renewed race. American modernization would need a faster battle line to answer the new standard. The exchange also distinguishes the public appearance of Anglo-American rivalry from the American Navy's concern with Japan.