Why Haig's reputation resists a simple rehabilitation
Veterans' welfare work adds context to Haig's reputation without removing criticism of his wartime conduct.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Pardons, firing squads, and historical judgment
The dispute separates criticism of wartime execution policy from judgment of soldiers ordered to carry it out, while acknowledging trauma and the limits of reconstructing individual cases.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Did Haig envisage alternatives to repeated costly attacks?
Haig's earlier preference for reserve mobilisation and the later Hundred Days qualify the idea that he envisaged only repeated frontal attacks.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Plumer and Rawlinson as possible successors to Haig
Plumer was the strongest field candidate and Rawlinson another plausible option, but either promotion would disrupt the command below Haig and require further replacements.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why suppressing a senior commander's memoir could backfire
Suppressing a prominent memoir could create rumours and disclose material through the legal dispute.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
The Hospitallers as a naval power
The Hospitallers' need for skilled sailors is used to explain cooperation across religious divisions.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How Dominion politics affected Western Front command
Command appointments had to account for Dominion governments and the confidence of the forces serving under them.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How repeated attacks sustained the Hundred Days offensive
Repeated attacks, trained troops, and improved artillery and mapping reduced German freedom to shift reserves along the front.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A comparison of British and German tactical flexibility
A shopping analogy explains the difference between following an instruction literally and adapting its means to fulfil the commander's purpose.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
The Royal Navy's shift toward task groups
The comparison follows the move from a concentrated fleet-battle expectation to forces organised for particular operations.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why an opponent must respond in a counterfactual
A useful counterfactual allows an enemy to adapt while keeping its responses within material limits.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How the inexperienced US Army learned on the Western Front
The discussion challenges a blanket judgment of American performance by considering experience, equipment, and the rate of learning.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig, a mechanized BEF, and the limits of radio coordination
The hypothetical comparison links ambitious plans to the radios, training, and clear instructions needed to carry them out.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Falklands landing craft could not be treated like trucks
Fifth Brigade's limited amphibious experience made scarce landing craft look like interchangeable transport, disrupting the tightly constrained unloading system.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why elite Canadian and Australian formations risked overuse
A Canadian recollection of unfair assignments is considered alongside the formations' combat reputation and limited replacement manpower.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Cornish mining expertise beyond Cornwall
Migration carried Cornish mining skills into overseas industry and wartime tunnelling.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Imagining Haig in Montgomery's campaigns
The comparison focuses on intelligence and command relationships rather than a worked alternative campaign.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Does World War II have an equivalent to the Hundred Days?
The comparison remains tentative because World War II spread learning across changing fronts, communications, and air situations.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Cornish tin and long-distance trade
Tin exports and imported wine illustrate the discussion's account of Cornwall's distant trading connections.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Mechanized spearheads and horse-drawn supply
Fast armored movement could outrun an army whose supporting transport still depended heavily on horses.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Haig is imagined in a cruiser command
The hypothetical naval career turns on independent station service and diplomacy.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why the Royal Navy relied on objective command
Distance from reliable communications made independent judgment part of meeting an assigned naval objective.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Malta convoys and the Mediterranean's separate campaigns
The Malta convoys lead into recommended naval staff histories and the need to distinguish separate Mediterranean operations.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How Cunningham combined simple operations to complicate enemy choices
Several clear tasks could combine into a much harder operational problem for an enemy.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Sicily, Normandy, and authority to protect the landing area
The comparison links the geography of a landing with the authority required to keep its naval screen effective.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
When a commander's original service matters less than systems management
At theater level, coordinating allies, resources, logistics, and disputes becomes more important than personally mastering every subordinate service's tactics.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why the game's République draws a turret-layout objection
The game design prompts a discussion of firepower concentration, redundancy, and the reasons for using quadruple turrets.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why miraculous Saxon oil would not immediately solve Germany's fuel problem
Oil discovered in Saxony in 1939 would require time and imported expertise to exploit while creating a concentrated target within British bombing range.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
What a third Dingyuan would add to availability
A third ship is considered chiefly as additional availability.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How the PLA fielded mass forces in the Korean War
The Communist army entered Korea as a force built around mass mobilization that had never fully demobilized after the Chinese Civil War.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Choosing between the DUKW and Terrapin
A maintenance-based preference favors the DUKW, while the answer leaves overall suitability dependent on the task.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Could a Chinese expeditionary corps secure Qingdao before Japan?
The answer turns the proposed Chinese contribution in France into a race to occupy Qingdao before Japan.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
The risks of releasing mines directly beneath a warship
The proposed weapon would require a submarine to approach extremely closely, exposing it to detection and nearby underwater explosions.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why battlefield success does not by itself define victory
Victory should be measured against political aims, so a state can inflict damage yet still lose when it fails to achieve the outcome for which it fought.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig in the Rif War counterfactual
Earlier colonial service is weighed against the scale and cost of the Franco-Spanish campaign.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Alhucemas did not become an Allied amphibious textbook
The answer attributes weak transmission of amphibious lessons to the absence of observers and usable accounts.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
What Britain might demand for additional treaty scrapping
In this counterfactual, scrapping nine additional ships would require permission for more Nelson-type battleships and F3-style battlecruisers.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A heavier 30-knot King George V proposal
A revised 14-inch armament and 30-knot speed are estimated to require roughly four to five thousand additional tons.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Dreadnought and South Carolina: speed despite equal broadsides
The comparison favors Dreadnought's sustained speed while noting that both ships could bring eight 12-inch guns to bear.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
NATO without the United States would face a logistics gap
The discussion sees sufficient potential combat forces but identifies strategic transport and medical evacuation capacity as the main constraint.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Can a screen give an uncrewed vehicle a presence mission?
A proposed avatar display tests the difference between remote communication and the commitment signaled by a crewed platform.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Outlaw fighting as policing rather than a military campaign
The answer distinguishes the purpose of law enforcement from the demands of a military campaign.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Two extra pre-dreadnoughts and wartime availability
Additional hulls are considered as a way to maintain squadron strength through availability losses.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Large rockets as an alternative to early torpedoes
The answer proposes large rocket projectiles as the development path that might have advanced if torpedoes failed.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Twelve Dingyuans would still need ammunition and trained crews
The hypothetical fleet is tested against the institutional conditions needed to use its ships together.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Grant's logistics turned losses into sustained pressure
Accounting, supply, and replacement capacity kept Grant's army operating through repeated losses.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A fifteen-gun Bayern and the volume of fire
The battery's advantage is explored through rate of fire and the distinction between shell count and calibre.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A US ten-and-ten battleship program in the 1890s
The suggested consequence is a later funding drought, leaving a large pre-dreadnought fleet while Congress delays its replacement.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·