Keeping an alternate Bayern out of foreign hands
The altered armament would preserve British interest in keeping advanced German ships from other navies.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
A starting point for studying Chinese military reform
Chinese Military Theory is offered as an accessible English-language starting point for reform and modernization, with an explicit warning that it is not definitive.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Three naval books to take to the Admiralty in 1905
Three technical histories would guide battleship, submarine and cruiser choices, with an imagined 1905 leap to centreline triple turrets and heavier guns.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
If Stalin received a French-scale fleet in 1938
A French-equivalent Soviet fleet would tie German capital ships to the Baltic and add a Pacific concern for Japan.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Assessing the game's Devastation as a British design
The game's heavy battery is considered broadly plausible, with the light antiaircraft fit drawing the main qualification.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why the Republic of China needed submarines more than cruisers
For the Republic of China in the early 1930s, concealed local sea denial offered more value than two light cruisers that lacked a supporting task force.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
How a 1909 super-steel would change British warship design
The imagined material advantage is spent on stronger hulls and armour backing; more ships would still require additional crews.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
The fragile kill chain behind long-range antiship missiles
A missile's advertised range matters only when reconnaissance can detect, identify, track, update, and strike a moving ship before the targeting picture expires.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Judging historical work by research quality
Judge historical work by its research quality, and consider whether an absent author has a fair chance to answer public criticism.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why USS Olympia needs expensive underwater preservation
The answer suggests dry-docking, repainting and possible hull-plate replacement, while stressing that Olympia has not been personally inspected.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Flags of convenience and the burden of naval protection
Cheap registration depends partly on protection provided by other naval powers, while ownership and flag can point to different national responsibilities.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why reloading vertical-launch cells at sea remains difficult
The proposed test is reliable reloading of many cells underway, with dedicated handling equipment built into the warship.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Royal Navy commanders known for personal marksmanship
Jellicoe and Hood lead a tentative First World War shortlist, with other Royal Navy commanders suggested for the age of sail, the Second World War, and the Falklands era.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Using naval staff histories and Jellicoe to approach the original record
Published staff histories and Jellicoe's own Grand Fleet account give readers unusually direct access to official wartime analysis and a commander's contemporary perspective.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Israel maintains a comparatively small navy
The answer links Israel's comparatively small navy to immediate land threats and the protection other Mediterranean powers provide to shared trade routes.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Rebuilding merchant shipping after the First World War
Tax incentives would pair new turbine ships with refits, sustain British yards, prepare merchantmen for wartime armament and seek 18-knot cruising speed.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
One starting book for the whole Second World War
Phillips Payson O'Brien's How the War Was Won is recommended as a broad starting point, not as an account whose every interpretation must be accepted.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A critique of the Dingyuan class's gun layout and seakeeping
The critique connects awkward gun arcs and poor seakeeping with a design judged poorly matched to Chinese requirements.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Rebuilding North Korea's navy as a submarine-heavy junior force
A hypothetical submarine-heavy junior force would cover local sea-denial duties and release Chinese submarines for other tasks.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Frigate numbers for a larger Royal Navy escort fleet
An initial forty-frigate estimate rises to forty-five after allowing for support to the SSBN force.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Russia is unlikely to buy a Chinese-built carrier
Buying from China may be technically practical, but carrier construction is too closely tied to Russian status and national prestige.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
A Deutschland-class ship in the German battle line
A Deutschland could potentially distract cruisers or draw capital-ship fire away from another German ship.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Russia could buy Mistrals but not a foreign carrier
An amphibious ship could be presented as a useful imported tool, while a foreign-built carrier would concede that Russia could not produce its premier naval symbol.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
The limits of adding catapults to amphibious assault ships
Deck catapults compete with helicopter space, while shorter hangar-level drone catapults are suggested as another possible arrangement.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Britain discarded Lend-Lease aircraft after the war
The answer links disposal of damaged Lend-Lease aircraft to the expense of restoring them before return, when they were expected to be scrapped.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Converting Ranger and Wasp into aviation support carriers
A support conversion could suit Ranger and eventually Wasp, while American use of forward island aviation bases offered another approach.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Giuseppe Garibaldi could not simply operate Rafales
The aircraft's operating requirements must fit the ship; changing either enough to make them compatible would be extremely expensive.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Rebuilding Britain's 1946-1960 logistics network
The proposal connects ports and power stations to rail and develops a freight backbone with less interference from passenger traffic.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Did American authorities know about aircraft disposal?
The follow-up describes mutual awareness of surplus disposal and the costs of repairing or transporting unwanted equipment.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Would a carrier's guns add much at Cape Matapan?
A carrier's smaller guns compared with the close-range fire of three battleships already engaging the cruisers.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why Pakistan still needs surface warships
Even against a larger Indian fleet, Pakistani surface ships provide presence, escort, air defense, and a visible layer around coastal and commercial interests.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Designing a 35-knot Lexington-style battlecruiser
The suggested starting point is a Tiger-derived arrangement with eight 16-inch guns, aiming for 35 knots if achievable.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why the post-Cold War shipyard contraction is criticised
The response calls the contraction understandable in its post-Cold War context while criticising the decision to allow it.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Can steady production reduce shipyard delays?
The proposed route to better shipyard performance is a sustained flow of construction work.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
MacArthur's authority over naval forces was theater command
MacArthur could set theater objectives and allocate priorities, but naval commanders still planned and executed the specialized maritime operations needed to achieve them.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Douglas Haig as an absorber and administrator of doctrine
Haig's strength lay in absorbing ideas, building organizations, and disseminating doctrine, while original tactical insight and independent criticism were weaker parts of his command.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig's attempt to limit patronage in staff appointments
Centrally assigned staff could limit patronage and let Haig resist pressure to appoint well-connected relatives.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig's early career, patronage, and army reform
Staff education, patronage, colonial service, and Haldane's reforms prepared Haig for administration and cavalry command but did not eliminate important blind spots.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig's artillery blind spot and aptitude for maneuver
Cavalry experience and the difficulty of moving heavy guns help explain Haig's emphasis on manoeuvre and exploitation.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig entered the First World War prepared for a different conflict
Early campaigns exposed the gap between prewar expectations and industrial war while casualties, coalition friction, and training demands reshaped British command.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why European staff systems resembled one another
The explanation points to copying a victorious army's staff system after the Franco-Prussian War.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Exam entry and sponsored places at staff college
The German comparison remains uncertain, while British sponsorship and exam entry are explained separately.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Loos, reserve disputes, and Haig's rise to command
The Battle of Loos combined coalition pressure, gas, and a bitter reserve dispute that helped Haig replace Sir John French.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
What constrained Haig's choices on the Somme
The Somme relieved pressure on Verdun at severe cost, while ammunition, transport and coalition demands constrained the hoped-for breakthrough.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why fodder cuts threatened more than cavalry
Fodder supported the pack and transport animals that sustained units beyond the reach of railways.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Learning under Haig and the Hundred Days payoff
Plumer, Rawlinson, and the wider British command system learned to integrate artillery, infantry, tanks, and maneuver before the Hundred Days.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Why replacing Haig was harder than condemning him
Troop confidence, coalition politics, command disruption, and the lack of an obvious replacement all raised the cost of removing Haig during the war.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·
Haig's defeat by aerial reconnaissance in an exercise
A smaller exercise force with aerial reconnaissance exposes the limits of numerical superiority.
From Historiophon 2025: part 2 of 9 - Friends of HMCS Haida ·