Notable Point · 1:34:35 The closing design exercise asks what a continuing British medium armoured-cruiser line might have produced alongside the dreadnought fleet.
From Cressy(1899) Class: Famous for the Wrong Things - 19th Century Cruisers Series 2 Part 12 · 21 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 9:44 A brief reading exchange pairs The Jutland Scandal with a published naval staff appreciation whose diagrams were redrawn by John Jordan.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 15:20 A question about HMS Tiger opens a comparison between David Beatty's appetite for the newest flagship and John Jellicoe's more restrained command style.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 22:25 A comparison of political thrift distinguishes Britain's reluctant treaty-era spending from the United States' frequent refusal to fund even permitted naval strength.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 23:51 A short answer identifies American warships as the strongest candidates for the best crew accommodation from the nineteenth century to 1940.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 24:07 A design question weighs the space and stability of trimarans against the weak combat evidence available for true multihulled warships.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 31:33 A Fisher counterfactual rebuilds the planned Revenge group as Renown-like battlecruisers armed with nine 15-inch guns.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 45:18 Ian Valentine's updated paperback HMS London is recommended for its illustrations and coverage through the Type 26 frigate.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 51:00 A reading from a study of HMS London places the cruiser at Shanghai as the Amethyst Incident unfolded on the Yangtze in April 1949.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 57:44 A survey of the Trafalgar Chronicle shows how the collection connects Georgian naval warfare with engineering, gunnery, navigation, medicine, natural history, and biography.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:00:45 A reading recommendation uses a Naval Institute guide to the Battle of Midway to connect interwar U.S. Navy planning with wartime execution.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:03:18 A counterfactual about Rear Admiral Robert English separates his likely limited effect on wartime operations from a potentially larger postwar influence on American submarine doctrine.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 1:05:39 A brief aside remembers Lieutenant Edna Morrow, a terminally ill nurse travelling home aboard the flight that killed Robert English.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:08:08 A question about Britain's equivalent to the U.S. Navy Seabees points to a commando-trained Royal Engineers formation that supports expeditionary operations.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:11:46 A short procurement answer separates the technical attraction of British machinery from its financial and industrial costs to France.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:14:49 A Jutland question argues that the Grand Fleet's advantage extended beyond ship numbers because Germany lacked an operational match for the Queen Elizabeth class.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:25:11 An early-modern shipping question explains why sailors could leave a merchant ship while cargo was handled and sign onto another vessel.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:26:51 The Dunkerque class is rated highly, and a larger fleet of the type would have sharpened British concern in 1940.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:29:02 The small caretaker complement of a ship in ordinary and the dockyard system needed to sustain an operational reserve fleet.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:31:16 A historiographical question treats sailors as one part of a wider maritime network that carried political ideas, passengers, and books between Europe and America.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:34:39 A comparative exercise uses the Town, Yorktown, Bismarck, and Yamato classes to illustrate British, American, German, and Japanese design tendencies.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:42:13 A Second World War intelligence question distinguishes acquiring information from judging its relevance and possessing forces able to act on it.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 1:45:24 A preview of German heavy-cruiser policy distinguishes the ideal Plan Z force, intended employment of ships already available, and actual wartime operations.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 1:47:29 A Cressy-class tactical example shows armoured cruisers reinforcing a superior battle line and helping envelop an enemy from both van and rear.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:51:35 A reading recommendation directs philosophically inclined military-history readers to Lawrence Freedman's broad study Strategy.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:52:25 A Tirpitz counterfactual contrasts the historical numerical race with a smaller German fleet competing mainly through battleship technology.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:56:24 A German cruiser counterfactual contrasts an efficient nine-gun 8-inch design with a more heavily armed replacement for treaty-bound pre-dreadnoughts.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 1:59:18 A comparison of Gato, T, and U-class submarines makes theater and concept of operations the starting point for judging design quality.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 2:00:36 A speculative gun-calibre hierarchy reserves 20-inch weapons for one or two prestige super-battleships while 16- and 18-inch ships perform most fleet work.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:05:41 A source question traces Ralph Edwards through operational planning, sea command, fleet staff work, procurement leadership, and a surviving archival collection.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:08:22 A calibre question notes that British work above the 15-inch gun repeatedly returned to a 16.5-inch step rather than stopping at a conventional 16-inch figure.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:09:33 The Royal Navy's protected-cruiser ratings organized capability and assignments while the common cruiser label also amplified diplomatic and political signalling.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:18:01 A treaty counterfactual directs most additional British tonnage toward County-class cruisers, with a possible third Nelson-class capital ship.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:21:01 A paired reading recommendation points to Ian Valentine's HMS London for a County-class study and Neil McCart for the Town class.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:23:27 Starting the King George V class in 1931 removes the later political setting that favored the historical 14-inch battery.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:26:39 A long-range submarine comparison gives the early-war advantage to Britain's Rainbow class before American fleet boats became the stronger late-war answer.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:29:25 The limited fame of French Second World War submarines is attributed to France's short campaign rather than fundamentally poor equipment.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:29:52 A lighthearted bookshelf question expands a Norman Friedman and Drachinifel reading plan by adding Andrew Lambert.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:35:09 An assessment of the Type VII U-boat separates weaker early variants from the more successful Type VIIC and specialized Type VIIF.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:37:28 A concise answer confirms that submarine abolition attracted very strong support in Britain around the London Naval Conference.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:38:19 A question about Revolutionary-era submersibles broadens the story beyond the American Turtle to French, British, and private experiments.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 2:39:01 A counterfactual fleet program connects earlier King George V construction with armour production, selective Queen Elizabeth refits, and faster follow-on battleship building.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:41:10 Industrial availability, not abstract preference, makes six 14-inch guns the likely armament for a British Second World War super-cruiser.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:41:54 A hypothetical rearmouring of HMS Hood turns on whether improved plate preserves belt thickness or trades thickness for wider coverage at the same weight.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:45:36 A future-weapons question suggests that renewed electromagnetic-gun development could push naval calibres beyond six inches.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:46:29 A preservation thought experiment selects ships that would add a destroyer, armoured carrier, battleship, pre-dreadnought, and wartime sloop to the surviving Royal Navy collection.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Q&A · 2:50:24 An escort taxonomy separates merchant-standard corvettes from naval-standard sloops and theoretically larger, faster destroyer escorts.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022
Notable Point · 2:56:12 A book review recovers the late nineteenth-century gas tram as a low-capital alternative to horse, steam, and electric street transport.
From Bruships 92: New Books, Naval Chat and Late 19th Century Warships... · 20 Nov 2022