Video
Soviet Navy Part 3/3: 1965-1991 - Trying to Win Cold War before it turned Hot?
Study Soviet Navy Part 3/3: 1965-1991 - Trying to Win Cold War before it turned Hot?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 17 Dec 2022, with 30 time notes. Topics include Cold War, Defence Economics, Force Structure.
Time notes
- 1:06The high-medium-low mix and the Krivak gapChapter
A ship's place in a fleet depends on the threat and its companions. The Krivaks lacked the prestige needed to cover the Soviet Navy's medium tier.
- 6:05Why the late Soviet Navy was builtChapter
Geography constrained Soviet fleets in a European war. The case for their global deployments gives greater weight to political influence before hostilities.
- 8:47Command economics behind Soviet naval diplomacyNotable Point
A command economy can concentrate resources behind a chosen idea, but choosing poorly makes that concentration costly. Access to resources helps explain the diplomatic role assigned to the navy.
- 11:40Resources and the cost of competing with Western financeNotable Point
London and New York had financial infrastructure that a Soviet rival would have to build. Expanding a network of friendly states offered another route to resources and influence.
- 13:19The space race and changing the test of prestigeNotable Point
The space race illustrates how political prestige depends on the achievement being judged. A proposed Soviet lunar base is a hypothetical alternative goal.
- 14:29Surface raiders and submarine dilemmasNotable Point
A gun-armed surface raider can attack merchant traffic while accompanying submarines threaten the carrier force sent to stop it.
- 17:51Why bombers do not provide a cheap answer to a raiderNotable Point
Attacking a distant raider with land-based aircraft requires bases or tankers and competes with the air campaign over Europe.
- 19:50Friendly neutrals and supplies for a long warNotable Point
Soviet efforts to court India and states in Africa and South America sought supplies and possible operating access if a war continued.
- 21:12Why the Moskva class carried so many helicoptersNotable Point
Moskva's large helicopter hangar addressed a fleet-wide anti-submarine need, even though the ship's overall design receives a poor assessment.
- 22:26Papa-class speed and the Spearfish responseChapter
The one-off Papa-class submarine paired a speed record with limited fleet numbers, forcing a British torpedo response whose publicity value was much smaller.
- 26:11Kara-class firepower and the medium-tier mismatchNotable Point
Kara's large missiles and radars conveyed power during port visits, but the ships were costly for the routine role the Soviet medium tier needed to fill.
- 30:32Alpha-class speed and the all-officer crewChapter
The Alpha class's speed and 31-officer crew exposed problems in conscript training, NCO recruitment, and the later careers of its technical specialists.
- 36:42Kiev's cruiser, command, and aviation rolesChapter
Kiev combined a missile cruiser bow, task-group command facilities, and an aviation deck. Its hybrid layout needs to be assessed across all those functions.
- 40:20Yak-38s, aircraft identification, and peacetime interceptionNotable Point
Embarked aircraft could identify and discourage reconnaissance flights around Soviet ships while giving commanders alternatives to firing missiles.
- 43:20Kirov as a prestige capital ship beside SlavaChapter
Kirov's size and armament created a difficult diplomatic comparison for Western navies, while Slava filled the more conventional cruiser role.
- 49:09Why shadowing Kirov became a political problemNotable Point
Watching a Soviet ship for covert activity could be a patrol-vessel task, but photographs beside Kirov created pressure to send a larger ship.
- 51:31How conscript personnel shaped Soviet naval equipmentNotable Point
Limited access to experienced NCOs encouraged rugged Soviet equipment and more technical work for junior officers, with consequences for naval adaptations of land systems.
- 53:09Typhoon and Delta as status procurementNotable Point
Overlapping Delta and Typhoon construction raises a procurement question: how much did the world's largest SSBN add militarily, and how much of its appeal was prestige?
- 58:45Peacetime appearance and the politics of naval imageNotable Point
A gleaming parade ship can look more powerful to the public than a weathered vessel returning from hard service, even when appearance says little about capability.
- 1:02:11Kuznetsov and Gorshkov's fallChapter
Kuznetsov promised a stronger carrier presence for global diplomacy, while its cost contributed to the pressures surrounding Gorshkov's fall.
- 1:03:11Why Liaoning and Shandong differ from KuznetsovNotable Point
A common hull origin does not settle a comparison between Kuznetsov, the reconstructed Liaoning, and the Chinese-built Shandong.
- 1:04:48Gorshkov's succession and the programs that continuedNotable Point
Gorshkov's departure in 1985 did not end major Soviet naval construction. Nearly thirty years in command had also shaped the officers available to succeed him.
- 1:09:40Chernavin keeps the submarine projectsNotable Point
Vladimir Chernavin preserved existing submarine programs and placed more weight on practical fighting capability while restricting new projects.
- 1:12:03Kirov's political pressure and the Iowa responseNotable Point
Iowa's reactivation provides a proposed political answer to Kirov: a battleship whose size and 16-inch guns could make an equally strong impression in port.
- 1:13:29Neustrashimyy class and the missing medium tierChapter
The Neustrashimyy class offered the balanced medium combatant missing from the earlier Soviet fleet, but arrived too late to alter its public image before the collapse.
- 1:15:01Gaps and assumptions in Soviet naval history booksNotable Point
Separate literatures on World War II and the later Cold War leave awkward gaps for a history of the Soviet Navy across its whole existence.
- 1:17:26Judge warships by their geostrategic compromisesNotable Point
A notional perfect warship helps only when it exposes real design compromises. National geography and treaty circumstances prevent one ideal cruiser from fitting every navy.
- 1:19:14Naval strategy as procurement strategyChapter
Procurement can reveal a navy's intended capabilities, including diplomatic influence. The claim that this dominated Soviet naval strategy is explicitly presented as contentious.
- 1:19:36Delaying NATO and the question of a seaborne deterrentNotable Point
Coastal delay and ballistic-missile submarines remain military roles in the argument, even as it questions how essential the seaborne deterrent was to the Soviet Union.
- 1:21:10How raiders could remove shipping without sinking itNotable Point
Failure to protect merchant shipping could persuade states to change flags and routes, removing hulls from NATO's supply system without a sinking.