Video
Patreon 23: Coal, Canals, Convoys & Coastal Carrying: traffic around the British isles from 1939-45
Study Patreon 23: Coal, Canals, Convoys & Coastal Carrying: traffic around the British isles from 1939-45, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 14 May 2021, with 57 time notes. Topics include Convoy Warfare, Inland Waterways…
Time notes
- 7:44QuestionHow difficult are historical ships' logs to read?AnswerQ&A
They can be physically and intellectually demanding because researchers must spend long periods deciphering difficult handwriting in archival volumes.
- 13:16Coastal convoys as Britain's wartime distribution networkChapter
Britain's home-water commands and coastal convoys connected ocean arrivals to ports around the country when roads and railways could not absorb the whole burden.
- 17:10QuestionDid the Royal Navy still need Jellicoe-style coal traffic during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Not on the First World War scale: the fleet was overwhelmingly oil-fired, although some coal-burning ships remained and coal still moved extensively by rail and sea.
- 18:08QuestionWas Britain's coastal shipping as important as its domestic railways during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
It was at least as important, and perhaps more so, because ships distributed imports among ports that neither the railways nor the limited road-haulage system could handle alone.
- 22:16QuestionDid narrow, old British canals seriously limit wartime transport capacity?AnswerQ&A
Not to the same extent as after the war; larger postwar loads exposed constraints created especially by bridges and built-up infrastructure around the canals.
- 23:44How coastal convoy codes mapped Britain's shipping networkNotable Point
The dense list of BB, BC, BD, BK, BTC, and other route codes reveals a scheduled network linking British ports, Irish traffic, and ocean-bound convoys.
- 26:06The scale and cost of Britain's coastal shipping campaignNotable Point
Loss figures show that coastal waters could be deadlier than the North Atlantic early in the war, despite the campaign's low profile in popular memory.
- 29:29QuestionDid German mines and attacks shift British coastal traffic away from the east coast?AnswerQ&A
They disrupted and reshaped traffic, but Britain had no adequate substitute, so convoys continued under minesweeping protection.
- 30:45QuestionWere coastal shipping losses mainly caused by the slow speed of the ships?AnswerQ&A
Not by speed alone; coastal convoys remained exposed to submarines, mines, Luftwaffe aircraft, and E-boats throughout the campaign.
- 31:52QuestionWhat was the average speed of a British coastal convoy?AnswerQ&A
A convoy generally moved at the speed of its slowest ship, while age, loading, maintenance, and weather made a single reliable average misleading.
- 34:09QuestionHow much oil did Britain have available during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Britain entered the war with large stocks built up from prewar planning, enough that fuel could be reserved for flame defenses on threatened beaches as well as normal military use.
- 36:29QuestionDid German attacks reach shipping in the Bristol Channel?AnswerQ&A
Yes; traffic serving Cardiff, Newport, and other Bristol Channel ports was within the coastal campaign's reach.
- 37:12QuestionHow might Scottish independence affect the Royal Navy?AnswerQ&A
Submarine basing and some ship construction would probably move south, increasing the importance of Devonport, Portsmouth, Southampton, Cammell Laird, and possibly Belfast.
- 38:42Coastal convoys faced every kind of wartime hazardChapter
U-boats, E-boats, aircraft, mines, shore guns, weather, and widely different merchant ships made coastal escort work unusually demanding.
- 46:23Radio silence complicated coastal convoy controlNotable Point
Sealing merchant radios protected a convoy's position but left its few escorts responsible for every radio warning and instruction.
- 48:34Convoy commodores kept merchant formations togetherChapter
Retired naval officers and experienced merchant captains served as convoy commodores, enforcing course, speed, and instructions from a merchant flagship.
- 55:57QuestionWhich British coastal convoy route carried the most traffic?AnswerQ&A
Traffic was heavy around the whole coast, with especially intense flows on the east and south coasts and from the west coast toward London.
- 57:10QuestionDid British coastal convoys receive regular land-based fighter cover?AnswerQ&A
Air cover was intended, but early-war shortages and the limited endurance of Hurricanes and Spitfires made continuous protection difficult until longer-ranged aircraft became more available.
- 58:09QuestionWhat traffic used Milford Haven, and how busy was the port?AnswerQ&A
It was very busy, handling local and passing traffic as part of a system that used every viable port.
- 58:48QuestionWere ocean-going merchant ships diverted so coastal vessels could distribute their cargo?AnswerQ&A
Usually the ocean-going ship entered a major defended port and then joined coastal convoys to reach the port nearest its cargo's destination.
- 1:01:57QuestionWere long-range aircraft such as Liberators available for coastal convoy patrols in 1939-40?AnswerQ&A
Not in useful numbers that early; some convoy cover instead fell to aircraft such as the Swordfish because it could remain airborne for long periods.
- 1:04:15War channels balanced mines, submarines, and navigationNotable Point
Britain's marked and swept coastal routes had to be deep and wide enough for shipping while remaining shallow enough to restrict submarine attacks.
- 1:06:32QuestionWhat effect might several small British escort carriers with Swordfish have had early in the Battle of the Atlantic?AnswerQ&A
They could have raised early U-boat losses, disproportionately removing Germany's scarce prewar-trained crews and improving convoy survival later in the war.
- 1:10:36QuestionDid the Royal Navy build more ships resembling HMS Unicorn during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
The Colossus and Majestic light fleet carriers show a strong design resemblance to Unicorn, with modifications for their different role.
- 1:12:16Why carrier stores compete with aircraft for hangar spaceNotable Point
HMS Queen Elizabeth's hangar shows why a larger air group requires more support shipping as well as more parking space.
- 1:12:52A wreck map traces Britain's coastal convoy routesNotable Point
Clusters and lines of Second World War wrecks make the convoy lanes and their assembly points visible along Britain's east coast.
- 1:20:54QuestionCould a British dry dock accommodate a US Navy supercarrier?AnswerQ&A
Southampton's King George V dock was large enough in principle, although its gates had been removed and it would require recommissioning.
- 1:27:57Small warships formed the coastal convoy escort poolChapter
Armed trawlers, patrol craft, gunboats, and small purpose-built classes supplied the numbers needed to protect Britain's many simultaneous coastal convoys.
- 1:34:00QuestionWhat distinguishes an attack, raid, action, skirmish, battle, and operation?AnswerQ&A
The terms overlap and depend heavily on the writer's perspective: an operation may include a raid or battle, while the same event can be classified differently in different accounts.
- 1:35:33QuestionWas the stern placement of merchant-ship guns a tactical choice?AnswerQ&A
It was principally a legal classification: an aft-mounted gun was treated as defensive, whereas a forward-mounted gun could make the ship appear offensively armed.
- 1:39:46QuestionWas Britain's canal network expanded during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
It was used intensively rather than substantially enlarged, building on a network that already carried significant traffic before the war.
- 1:40:15QuestionWhat was the usual rank of an armed trawler's commanding officer?AnswerQ&A
Typically a lieutenant, often from the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve; some civilian trawler skippers received wartime commissions and retained command of their vessels.
- 1:41:36QuestionWhen did the Royal Navy begin installing air conditioning in its ships?AnswerQ&A
Ventilation experiments began in the interwar decades, limited air-conditioning installations appeared from about the 1960s, and adoption widened after the First Gulf War.
- 1:48:06QuestionWere Q-ships concealed among British coastal convoys?AnswerQ&A
Sometimes; disguised armed vessels could accompany coastal traffic as part of its protection.
- 1:51:28Canals saved fuel and carried Britain's heavy wartime freightChapter
Britain's inland waterways moved roughly 12 million tons of essential goods a year while saving petrol, rubber, road capacity, and coastal shipping space.
- 1:55:21Women boat crews and canals on the British home frontChapter
Women crews moved steel and coal along inland waterways after brief training, while the canals themselves became defended transport arteries and anti-invasion lines.
- 2:01:43Canal mines brought naval bomb disposal onto dry landNotable Point
German mines aimed at rivers and canals sometimes landed in streets, houses, or factories, requiring naval specialists to work alongside Army and RAF disposal teams.
- 2:08:17Canals as anti-invasion stop linesChapter
British defense planners incorporated canals into layered stop lines because their known depth, banks, and crossings created predictable obstacles to an invader.
- 2:13:10QuestionHow did coastal convoys cope with supplying Europe after D-Day?AnswerQ&A
The task was difficult, but more escorts were assigned and the Channel approaches were heavily barred while German attention shifted toward cross-Channel traffic.
- 2:14:23QuestionWhy did Derby receive special protection in Britain's anti-invasion plans?AnswerQ&A
It was the center of a northern defensive line and an inland redoubt whose loss would open a dangerous route deeper into Britain.
- 2:14:45QuestionDid Japan use small vessels to supply Guadalcanal because they were difficult for American aircraft to attack?AnswerQ&A
Japan used many small craft, but American pilots still attacked them, and aircrew claims often exaggerated the size and destruction of their targets.
- 2:15:49QuestionWhen did fears of a German invasion of Britain recede?AnswerQ&A
They diminished after Germany invaded the Soviet Union in 1941 and had committed the forces needed for a cross-Channel invasion elsewhere, with the shift clear by about 1942.
- 2:16:16QuestionWere there canal gunboats, and who operated them?AnswerQ&A
Some canal craft carried weapons and were operated by Army organizations such as the Royal Engineers rather than the Royal Navy.
- 2:18:39QuestionWere barges or hulks armed to defend British waterways from air attack?AnswerQ&A
Yes; vessels carried anti-aircraft guns, and larger offshore forts also protected approaches such as the Thames against aircraft and surface threats.
- 2:19:12QuestionHow did the Royal Air Force use Britain's canals?AnswerQ&A
Some airfields near canals received ammunition and other heavy supplies by water, reducing the burden and risk of moving bulky cargo by road.
- 2:23:59The Inland Waterways women as a national war workforceNotable Point
The women marked IW for Inland Waterways endured an unfair nickname while performing hard, mobile work that linked factories and cities across Britain.
- 2:26:49QuestionWere British canal crews used on waterways captured during the Allied advance in Europe?AnswerQ&A
Generally local crews operated their own waterways, while canals were too slow and geographically fixed to keep pace with rapidly advancing field forces.
- 2:30:54The Royal Navy's heavy anti-invasion backstopNotable Point
Britain's canal stop lines formed only one layer of defense; capital ships, cruisers, and destroyers were also positioned to attack a German invasion fleet.
- 2:34:01QuestionWere Britain's coastal convoy ships rerouted to continental ports after D-Day?AnswerQ&A
A largely separate shipping pool handled the immediate supply effort, although larger merchant ships could enter once captured ports were cleared and restored.
- 2:34:21How delayed Norwegian mobilization aided the German invasionNotable Point
Norway could have mobilized in defense of neutrality and forced German landing groups to confront manned forts and organized troops.
- 2:36:56QuestionWhat casualties did Britain's women canal crews suffer?AnswerQ&A
No total is given; casualties appear limited, although crews faced strafing, mines, and other attacks and some women were killed.
- 2:41:08QuestionHow might an Allied victory in Norway in 1940 have changed the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
It could have shortened the war by denying German bases and Norwegian resources, constraining U-boats, and making the Arctic supply route to the Soviet Union much easier to protect.
- 2:45:54QuestionWhat would have happened if Germany had invaded Iceland?AnswerQ&A
Germany lacked the lift and support to hold it; a small force delivered by major warships would face a larger British counter-invasion and expose its supporting ships.
- 2:48:16QuestionWhat was the British counterpart to US Navy Armed Guard crews on merchant ships?AnswerQ&A
Britain used naval and other service personnel in the Defensively Equipped Merchant Ships organization, commonly abbreviated DEMS.
- 2:51:58QuestionHow might an Allied-held Norway have affected Sweden and Finland?AnswerQ&A
Sweden would probably lean toward the Allies, while Finland might remain neutral rather than renew war with the Soviet Union alongside Germany.
- 2:53:43QuestionWas the Russian destroyer Novik related to the British Town-class cruisers?AnswerQ&A
No direct relationship is identified; Novik and her class are still described as interesting, well-designed destroyers.
- 2:55:55QuestionDid Britain intervene in Norway after the fighting at Narvik?AnswerQ&A
Yes, but the campaign was conducted half-heartedly and hampered by a poor command structure.