Video

Empire Total War Twitch Stream 9(April 2023)

Study Empire Total War Twitch Stream 9(April 2023), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 17 Apr 2023, with 45 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Arthur Wellesley, Battleships.

Date
Runtime3:59:53
Guide points45 time notes

Time notes

  1. 9:18
    QuestionCould X-craft have been used to lay nuclear mines in the 1950s?Answer

    The possibility was examined, but no navy actually adopted the mission.

    Q&A
  2. 10:14
    Fleet concentration rather than one-on-one duels

    A Royal Navy force-design point explains why a fleet built to concentrate several ships matters more than a single-ship comparison.

    Notable Point
  3. 18:21
    QuestionHow should a battleship balance very heavy armour against its guns and speed?Answer

    A useful design sits between protection, firepower, and speed; piling on armour consumes weight that could support speed or other capabilities.

    Q&A
  4. 24:12
    Choosing naval gun size without sacrificing rate of fire

    A game-design aside explains why ever-larger battleship guns may be less useful than a heavy battery that still reloads quickly and puts many barrels on target.

    Notable Point
  5. 27:07
    Standardised armament and cruiser numbers

    A fleet-building discussion connects common gun calibres, repeat cruiser designs, and numerical concentration to logistical simplicity and combat power.

    Notable Point
  6. 30:21
    Artillery high ground, dead ground, and counter-battery fire

    A battle deployment uses commanding ground and dead ground to show how terrain determines what artillery can see, protect, and suppress.

    Notable Point
  7. 40:11
    The unrealised possibility of Second World War boarding actions

    A brief aside notes that destroyers sometimes closed with much heavier ships closely enough to make boarding imaginable, even though such opportunities did not become actual actions.

    Notable Point
  8. 41:26
    When a flanking move makes a position untenable

    A short tactical warning explains why defenders should abandon a position once an enemy moves around it and beyond the guns' field of fire.

    Notable Point
  9. 42:46
    Why an unattributed Rodney anecdote remains uncertain

    A recollection that Rodney's chief engineer was Welsh is left unconfirmed because the claim cannot be tied to a source during the stream.

    Notable Point
  10. 44:25
    How completed G3 and N3 ships could reshape treaty limits

    An alternate-history discussion traces how completed G3 battlecruisers and N3 battleships could alter treaty limits, rival building programmes, and later fleets.

    Chapter
  11. 47:59
    Tillman battleships as a naval-policy question

    A reassessment of the Tillman battleships separates Senator Tillman's policy question from the maximum battleship studies drawn by naval engineers and asks pro-navy viewers to recognise their own bias.

    Notable Point
  12. 54:26
    QuestionIf the G3s had gone ahead, might the unfinished Admiral-class ships have been converted to carriers?Answer

    He considers the conversion plausible and suggests the Admiral-class hulls could have replaced the smaller interwar conversion carriers.

    Q&A
  13. 57:03
    How political career incentives can produce groupthink

    A political aside distinguishes simple conformity from the career incentives that discourage officeholders from becoming conspicuous targets.

    Notable Point
  14. 59:56
    QuestionWould the poor tonnage efficiency of carrier conversions make Admiral-class conversions inferior to ships such as Ark Royal or Lexington?Answer

    Conversions are less efficient, but he argues that the much larger Admiral hulls would still provide substantial aircraft capacity and replace smaller converted carriers.

    Q&A
  15. 1:00:30
    QuestionWould the United States still be able to build up rapidly if an enemy controlled the Panama Canal?Answer

    The desire to mobilise would remain, but moving East Coast industry to the West Coast by sea would be slower and easier to obstruct without secure canal access.

    Q&A
  16. 1:01:47
    Why attacking prepared siegeworks wastes an army

    A game battle demonstrates how gun positions, a core force, held-back infantry, and a disposable forward line can absorb a counterattack before the defender takes the fort.

    Notable Point
  17. 1:14:57
    QuestionHow might a genuinely fast Nelson class have affected the hunt for Bismarck?Answer

    Faster Nelson-class ships could have altered the British hunting force, but readiness and refit state would still decide which ships sailed.

    Q&A
  18. 1:21:17
    QuestionWould nuclear propulsion make sense in a battleship?Answer

    He sees it as a poor fit: protecting a reactor inside a combat battleship would impose a major weight and layout penalty.

    Q&A
  19. 1:26:17
    Layered hilltop defence and waiting reserves

    A defensive setup covers likely approaches with several lines, keeps artillery on high ground, and treats the game's reinforcement limit as a reserve system.

    Notable Point
  20. 1:30:18
    QuestionCould a nuclear submarine serve as the detachable power, command, and escape module of a battleship?Answer

    Conceptually it could, but the combined vessel would be extraordinarily expensive rather than a practical historical design.

    Q&A
  21. 1:31:42
    Why bravery cannot rescue an uphill frontal assault

    A battle uses US Marines and cavalry to show that troop quality and courage cannot compensate for attacking uphill into prepared fire.

    Notable Point
  22. 1:46:25
    How hilltop fortresses secured water

    A discussion of elevated forts explains how wells, pipes, trenches, cisterns, and large storage rooms made defensible but water-poor positions viable.

    Chapter
  23. 1:50:31
    QuestionDid incomplete Russian fortifications affect the timing of Japan's attack?Answer

    Yes. He argues that Japan benefited from striking before the relevant Russian forts were available for effective use.

    Q&A
  24. 1:55:37
    QuestionCould the defenders have won at the Alamo?Answer

    Only in a strategic sense: stronger preparations or a longer defence might have held Santa Anna's army until a relieving field force arrived.

    Q&A
  25. 2:02:51
    How the Yorkie slogan turned provocation into publicity

    A consumer-history aside interprets Yorkie's exclusionary slogan as a provocation that encouraged oppositional buying and generated attention beyond paid advertising.

    Notable Point
  26. 2:04:26
    Patronage did not excuse failure in the British officer class

    A discussion of schools, family connections, and military careers argues that patronage opened doors in Britain but could not indefinitely protect an officer who visibly failed.

    Chapter
  27. 2:11:54
    QuestionWhy was the Royal Navy not an easy posting for an unsuccessful well-connected son?Answer

    The lieutenant's examination could expose failure publicly, so patronage did not remove every professional requirement.

    Q&A
  28. 2:16:52
    Why Wellesley's brother bought him a commission

    Arthur Wellesley's purchased commission is presented as both family advancement and a way for his brother, the governor in India, to secure regiments he could trust.

    Notable Point
  29. 2:18:53
    Why successful generals can struggle in democratic politics

    A comparison of command and politics explains why habits that serve a field general can conflict with negotiation, constitutional restraint, and democratic compromise.

    Chapter
  30. 2:25:42
    How shipboard command trains officers to allocate scarce resources

    A comparison of military and political leadership explains how captains continually balance fighting power, mobility, personnel, and the limits of what is already aboard ship.

    Notable Point
  31. 2:27:21
    Why government cannot be judged like a business

    A political-economy aside contrasts a firm's profit test with a government's obligation to balance health, education, security, and other collective needs.

    Notable Point
  32. 2:28:56
    QuestionDid an army the size of Wellington's require a large general staff?Answer

    Wellington did maintain a staff, but it was smaller and more specialised than later general-staff systems, with engineers and artillery officers prominent.

    Q&A
  33. 2:30:22
    How Bradley shaped the Patton-Montgomery rivalry on film

    A film-history aside argues that Omar Bradley's role advising Patton helped recast his own dispute with Montgomery as a broader American conflict with the British commander.

    Notable Point
  34. 2:31:06
    Cunningham, Alan Brooke, and naval policy

    A wartime command aside portrays Cunningham as an effective advocate for naval policy when Alan Brooke tried to shape it from the Army side.

    Notable Point
  35. 2:33:32
    Classical conservatism, liberalism, and human fallibility

    A political-theory aside presents government as a collective check on personal weaknesses and distinguishes older conservatism from modern ideological programmes.

    Notable Point
  36. 2:35:31
    QuestionWere people in the Mesolithic healthier than later populations until modern times?Answer

    Possibly, but the surviving skeletons may overrepresent people in unusually good condition and therefore require caution.

    Q&A
  37. 2:37:59
    Wellesley's emphasis on intelligence, engineering, and logistics

    A brief staff-history aside groups intelligence, engineering, and logistics among the functions Wellesley pushed forward.

    Notable Point
  38. 2:40:45
    QuestionWould Britain have failed to create the NHS if naval treaties had not halted capital-ship construction?Answer

    No. Earlier welfare reform, civil-defence needs, and existing local medical systems had already placed universal provision on a longer path.

    Q&A
  39. 2:47:11
    Why governments can benefit from moderate inflation

    A public-finance aside explains why a government issuing sustainable long-term debt may see moderate inflation reduce the real burden of repayment.

    Notable Point
  40. 2:49:14
    Why the NHS did not appear from nowhere

    A historiographical correction presents the NHS as a major reform assembled from existing medical networks, local organisations, and earlier policy reports rather than an institution invented in one step.

    Notable Point
  41. 2:57:18
    How wartime medicine changed doctors' view of public provision

    A medical-history point links service in First World War trenches and field hospitals to doctors becoming more comfortable with collective rather than exclusively private provision.

    Notable Point
  42. 2:59:12
    Capital-ship building, shipyards, and organised labour

    An alternate-history discussion links continued capital-ship construction to shipyard employment, coal mining, trade-union alliances, and the politics surrounding interwar welfare reform.

    Chapter
  43. 3:18:22
    QuestionWhen did artillery begin using gun shields against small-arms fire?Answer

    Early adoption is tentatively placed around the Boer War era, especially on lighter guns, with shields becoming more common afterward.

    Q&A
  44. 3:29:47
    Why firing artillery at Napoleon could backfire

    A tactical aside weighs the enormous reward of killing Napoleon against the much likelier morale cost of missing him with period artillery.

    Notable Point
  45. 3:33:36
    Were Wellington's public remarks polished for the record?

    A source-criticism aside compares Wellington's polished recorded speeches with the rougher voice in private letters and asks how much editors adapted for newspapers and public memory.

    Notable Point