Video
Empire Total War Twitch Stream 7(March 2023)
Study Empire Total War Twitch Stream 7(March 2023), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 27 Mar 2023, with 41 time notes. Topics include Age Of Sail, Battle Of Copenhagen, Combined Arms.
Time notes
- 3:13Remembering Admiral James GoldrickNotable Point
A remembrance of Australian admiral and naval historian James Goldrick gives particular attention to his personal kindness.
- 11:42A blockade exposes a brittle trade networkNotable Point
A blockade disrupts the game's trade income, forcing maximum taxes to maintain the army and prompting concern about unrest.
- 29:12Merchant income and the warships needed to protect itNotable Point
Interrupted trade exposes the risk in buying merchant ships to finance a larger navy before that commerce has adequate protection.
- 32:34Concentrating heavy ships against selected targetsNotable Point
A fleet battle plan assigns small enemy vessels to sixth rates while concentrating pairs of third rates against stronger opponents.
- 41:34Panama as an imperial chokepointNotable Point
Holding Panama in the campaign places an occupying army across Spain's reinforcement route between its American territories.
- 43:31Protecting artillery while keeping troops free to manoeuvreNotable Point
A town defence separates the artillery guard from a centrally placed manoeuvre force as the enemy advances toward the guns.
- 52:37Why an East Indiaman could resemble a fourth rateNotable Point
The game's East Indiaman is criticised for resembling a small brig or sloop instead of the expected fourth-rate-like trading ship.
- 55:15Finishing the American campaign before expanding into IndiaNotable Point
A prepared army creates an opportunity in India, but the campaign postpones that offensive while watching another power's growing reach.
- 56:33Grand strategy as joined-up thinkingNotable Point
Criticism of Spain's campaign decisions leads to a plain-language definition of grand strategy as 'joined-up thinking'.
- 1:01:33Fixed defences and the direction of attackNotable Point
Defenders abandon prepared positions that face the wrong approach, leaving their artillery exposed while the attackers use higher ground.
- 1:06:20Attacking artillery while keeping a cavalry reserveNotable Point
Four mounted units attack the enemy guns while a fifth covers the operation and waits to intercept interference.
- 1:21:31Using the wind and distance during a pursuitNotable Point
A pursuit raises a tradeoff between sailing against the wind, preserving separation, and keeping enemy ships away from earning trade income.
- 1:26:37Concentrating naval fire under the game's rulesNotable Point
A strong squadron plans to silence the enemy's principal fighting ship, but collisions complicate a battle expected to be easy.
- 1:36:47Ceylon as a check on Indian expansionNotable Point
Ceylon provides a defensible foothold against Maratha dominance, although the army stationed there still needs more artillery.
- 1:54:23Bomb vessels at CopenhagenNotable Point
A game battle prompts a concise explanation of why British bomb vessels mattered at Copenhagen in 1801.
- 2:06:02Supporting artillery without shooting friendly troopsNotable Point
Keeping infantry behind the guns provides protection, but their angle and movement require careful control of friendly fire.
- 2:08:54Galleons against rated warshipsNotable Point
A fleet encounter prompts a compact comparison between galleons and third-, fourth-, and fifth-rate warships.
- 2:16:50Damaging ports while Spain expands in EuropeNotable Point
Spain's conquest of France prompts an immediate attack on its ports while Britain decides whether to intervene on land.
- 2:29:14Could cavalry reputation shape infantry confidence?Notable Point
A deliberately speculative explanation links British infantry confidence against cavalry to familiarity with their own cavalry's uneven reputation.
- 2:32:49When commerce raiding fixes a battle fleet in placeNotable Point
Limited piracy losses are accepted because the raiding mission keeps a powerful Spanish fleet away from more important operations.
- 2:35:13British cavalry's difficulty stopping a chargeNotable Point
British cavalry's effective charges are weighed against difficulty stopping and interruptions in the service of capable officers.
- 2:36:39French infantry beyond the attack columnNotable Point
French infantry were more adaptable than the familiar image of massed attack columns suggests.
- 2:38:31Why remove the Prussian foothold first?Notable Point
A short campaign assessment prioritises removing Prussia as a land-war opponent in the Americas.
- 2:38:53Cavalry officers, reputation, and the choice of groundNotable Point
An assessment of cavalry command distinguishes deployment skill from the choice of battles and terrain.
- 2:48:47Changing dynasties and the Spanish EmpireNotable Point
A short aside links the Spanish Empire's changing direction to the different imperial approaches of Habsburg and Bonaparte rule.
- 2:52:50QuestionWhy not eliminate Spain in Europe and let its colonies break away?AnswerQ&A
The campaign follows a personal preference for a more historical, colony-first approach, despite the extra time it takes.
- 2:56:30Continental territory and land-war commitmentsNotable Point
The prospect of taking Paris challenges a campaign strategy that avoids European possessions and the land wars they are expected to bring.
- 2:57:15A diplomatic success creates a new strategic problemNotable Point
An attempt to loosen Franco-Spanish relations succeeds too well, leaving Spain dominant in western Europe and forcing an unwanted strategic pivot.
- 3:02:37Drawing infantry downhill with exposed artilleryNotable Point
An attempt to lure defenders off a hill shows both the attraction of artillery as bait and the risk of mistiming the trap.
- 3:08:53Reinforcing a fleet before a threat arrivesNotable Point
Concern about a possible Spanish deployment prompts reinforcement of an undersized Indian Ocean fleet.
- 3:09:15Could fleets fight in Arctic winter?Notable Point
Uncommon Arctic winter fleet actions are distinguished from single-ship actions and more frequent Baltic operations in wintry conditions.
- 3:11:40Poodles, Roman origins, and war-dog unitsNotable Point
A comment about war-dog units connects a game modification with a brief claim about poodles and the Roman Empire.
- 3:12:50Religious colleges and control of conquered territoryNotable Point
Jesuit and Protestant colleges become competing tools for keeping the population content and maintaining control in the game campaign.
- 3:30:53Why infantry squares surrender firepowerNotable Point
A game battle makes a combined-arms tradeoff visible: infantry squares deter cavalry but expose fewer muskets to an opposing firing line.
- 3:45:43A technology hub as an operational objectiveNotable Point
Philadelphia's research role makes it an urgent campaign objective, alongside the need to break the American field armies.
- 3:52:37Questioning refusals of profitable trade agreementsNotable Point
Refused trade agreements prompt the view that financial benefits should carry more weight when relations are indifferent.
- 3:53:04Operational access and the cost of expansionNotable Point
Planning an attack on Portugal connects coastal access and enemy troop concentration with the financial pause required after rapid conquest.
- 4:03:20When game fleet actions resemble cavalry combatNotable Point
The game's ship engagements invite cavalry-like tactics, alongside a fleet composition that differs from the historical comparison.
- 4:07:47Artillery exposure and a defender abandoning the positionNotable Point
An assault uses diversionary troops while defenders make the attack easier by leaving a position they should hold.
- 4:16:13Accepting a costly assault to save campaign timeNotable Point
An attack attempted with defeat expected becomes a costly victory, complicated by the loss of the general and an anticipated counterattack.
- 4:27:05Fences, fields of fire, and gaps in a defensive lineNotable Point
A defensive deployment leaves out fences to widen the field of fire, then places infantry where attackers approach a gap.