Video

Bruships 87: Books Found on My Travels, New Books & Christmas Recomendations

Study Bruships 87: Books Found on My Travels, New Books & Christmas Recomendations, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 9 Oct 2022, with 43 time notes. Topics include Book Recommendations, Live Q&A, Naval History.

Date
Runtime2:32:01
Guide points43 time notes

Time notes

  1. 18:00
    A modeler's guide to HMS Victory

    The first recommendation combines a compact history of HMS Victory with a survey of model kits, paint schemes, and scratch-building options.

    Chapter
  2. 22:20
    QuestionIf HMS Hood survived, would the Royal Navy still complete HMS Vanguard?Answer

    Probably yes; political and institutional inertia would favor completing a ship that embodied Britain's accumulated capital-ship knowledge.

    Q&A
  3. 23:48
    Shipwreck history through one hundred objects

    Sam Willis's object-based shipwreck history leads into the wreck of Sea Venture, the settlement of Bermuda, and the castaways' eventual voyage to Jamestown.

    Chapter
  4. 28:51
    QuestionWould Britain trade one day at the start of the Second World War to modernize every Royal Navy ship to the best 1939 standard?Answer

    Yes; the fleet-wide gains in engines, radar, armor, and anti-aircraft weapons would far outweigh losing one day.

    Q&A
  5. 31:09
    QuestionWhat guns would make a strong pre-Second World War coastal defense for the Falkland Islands?Answer

    County-class eight-inch turrets, arranged in several three-turret batteries, would impose a formidable barrier to attack.

    Q&A
  6. 33:10
    How airliner engines became commercial systems

    Powering the World's Airlines traces engine development from the 1930s and wartime production through turbojets, turbofans, and the economics of buying an airliner.

    Chapter
  7. 37:52
    QuestionWas HMS London's handling poor after modernization?Answer

    Its handling changed from race-car-like responsiveness to a rally car's need for more anticipation and tolerance of rougher conditions.

    Q&A
  8. 39:16
    QuestionWould modern cruise ships sent into a world war sail independently or in convoy?Answer

    Most would sail in convoy because they are too slow to operate safely alone; Queen Mary 2 might be an exception.

    Q&A
  9. 40:11
    QuestionShould the King George V class have used fifteen-inch or sixteen-inch guns instead of fourteen-inch weapons?Answer

    A high-quality fifteen-inch gun offers the strongest fleet-wide benefit because it could also modernize thirteen existing British capital ships.

    Q&A
  10. 42:53
    Military Heroes as warts-and-all biography

    Brian Lightbody's Military Heroes is recommended for concise biographies that preserve their subjects' flaws, illustrated by racing driver and First World War ace Eddie Rickenbacker.

    Chapter
  11. 47:13
    QuestionWhat difference would old eight-inch Falklands batteries make during the 1982 invasion?Answer

    They could badly damage or even stop the invasion force, but maintaining them would require a much larger garrison and layered air defense.

    Q&A
  12. 53:57
    A technical owner's manual for wartime U-boats

    A Haynes-style U-boat manual opens discussion of Type VII machinery, snorkels, and why late-war improvements could not overturn the adapting Allied anti-submarine system.

    Chapter
  13. 58:30
    QuestionDid the Type VII U-boat snorkel handle both intake and exhaust?Answer

    According to the featured Haynes manual, yes: it drew in fresh air and expelled diesel-engine air through the installation.

    Q&A
  14. 1:01:50
    The diplomatic battle around HMS Amethyst

    Escape of the Amethyst portrays a ship captain forced into a tense political contest over safe conduct, responsibility, and British national standing during the Yangtze Incident.

    Chapter
  15. 1:11:36
    QuestionCould Britain build capital ships and escorts at the same time without slowing escort construction?Answer

    Both could be built in parallel, but capital-ship work would inevitably reduce how quickly escorts could be produced.

    Q&A
  16. 1:12:37
    QuestionWhat if the CIA knowingly sank a British ship with all hands and the attack became public?Answer

    It would cause a major alliance and presidential-control crisis, probably forcing the agency to be renamed and reorganized.

    Q&A
  17. 1:16:08
    Prefabricated escorts met established shipyard practice

    A passage on wartime escort construction shows that prefabrication was as much an organizational challenge as a technical one in established British yards.

    Notable Point
  18. 1:19:54
    QuestionIs the story about the cat rescued from Bismarck reliable?Answer

    The same cat is claimed to have turned up alive in too many later places, which makes the story doubtful.

    Q&A
  19. 1:20:07
    QuestionHow would Britain react if the CIA mistakenly bombed a British diplomatic site in a counterfactual 1984?Answer

    Britain would be extremely angry, but the incident would probably be resolved diplomatically because the two countries would remain allies.

    Q&A
  20. 1:20:35
    A visual route into Royal Navy camouflage

    Malcolm Wright's illustrated camouflage volumes are recommended as accessible visual guides covering cruisers, escorts, destroyers, and sloops such as the Black Swan class.

    Chapter
  21. 1:25:53
    QuestionWhy combine exhaust with the snorkel instead of discharging it underwater despite the back pressure?Answer

    A combined installation could be the more practical retrofit for an older Type VII, even though snorkel exhaust created development and detection tradeoffs.

    Q&A
  22. 1:31:07
    QuestionCan one country really stop another sovereign power from acting?Answer

    Usually not if the state is determined; an ally's restraint often supplies diplomatic cover for a decision the state already prefers.

    Q&A
  23. 1:36:54
    Sea Power and Victory in wartime images

    An Imperial War Museum picture book surveys maritime warfare through cruiser blockades, kite balloons, submarine chasers, and a captured submarine.

    Chapter
  24. 1:50:06
    QuestionIf the necessary inputs were available by the end of 1942, could an Audacious-class carrier commission in 1944?Answer

    Yes; that timing is plausible and the ship might even enter service earlier.

    Q&A
  25. 1:50:49
    Warspite's sailors and the Invergordon pay crisis

    Battleship Sailors uses HMS Warspite's crew to show how unequal pay cuts, rumor, and weakened trust produced the Invergordon unrest.

    Chapter
  26. 1:55:43
    Jacky Fisher, the lower deck, and naval modernization

    Fisher's Face presents Admiral Jacky Fisher's affection for sailors, hostility to inherited status barriers, and belief that social reform supported combat effectiveness.

    Chapter
  27. 1:59:21
    QuestionWhat might happen if Zheng He's fleet met an early Portuguese fleet off West Africa?Answer

    The chronology must first be altered, and a cautious exchange or negotiation would be more likely than an immediate battle.

    Q&A
  28. 1:59:55
    QuestionDid the United States need new sixteen-inch shells because it had run out of Second World War ammunition?Answer

    New shells were required because wartime stocks could only be maintained for a limited time, even if many remained unused.

    Q&A
  29. 2:02:26
    QuestionWhat would change if triangular sails reached northern Europe one or two centuries earlier?Answer

    Longer-range sailing would probably begin earlier, but the immediate wider changes would be limited.

    Q&A
  30. 2:02:44
    QuestionWhy was the CIA pilot Alan Pope's missed attack on HMS Oryx so consequential?Answer

    The miss let the incident be set aside; hitting and sinking the British submarine would have created a serious alliance crisis.

    Q&A
  31. 2:03:32
    QuestionHow seriously did the Suez Crisis damage relations between Britain and the United States?Answer

    It fundamentally recast the relationship, replacing assumptions of equality with the language of a special friendship and influence beyond Britain's weight.

    Q&A
  32. 2:04:25
    QuestionCould an encounter with early Portuguese sailors lead Zheng He's fleet onward to Europe?Answer

    Possibly; after rounding the Cape the fleet might reach the Mediterranean and Europe, with outcomes ranging from contact to religious conflict.

    Q&A
  33. 2:05:50
    The Forgotten Dead and the purchase of a sunken Sherman

    Ken Small's The Forgotten Dead recounts the legal and bureaucratic campaign to buy a submerged Sherman tank as a memorial to American servicemen killed during wartime training.

    Chapter
  34. 2:13:48
    QuestionWhy did the French Navy not rebuild its carriers to British or American modernization standards?Answer

    France decided those conversions were unnecessary for its requirements and pursued other aviation choices instead.

    Q&A
  35. 2:15:29
    Preserving Mediterranean Fleet and Coastal Command magazines

    Three fragile period magazines cover the Mediterranean Fleet, Coastal Command, and the Atlantic bridge, linking naval and air dimensions of maritime war.

    Notable Point
  36. 2:22:02
    QuestionWhich warship designs would have been better never built?Answer

    HMS Captain is a leading example, although even disastrous ships and awkward ocean-going monitors taught navies something.

    Q&A
  37. 2:22:30
    QuestionWhy might Argentina expect Britain to sell it an Implacable-class carrier?Answer

    Britain might make the sale, but would probably balance it by selling the other carrier to Brazil.

    Q&A
  38. 2:23:32
    QuestionHow would small sailing ships armed with twelve or eighteen guns be rated?Answer

    Both would be unrated brigs of some type; the exact label would depend on rig, hull form, and purpose.

    Q&A
  39. 2:24:15
    QuestionWas HMS Victory the oldest ship used in combat as an anti-aircraft platform during the Second World War?Answer

    Possibly in a very broad sense, but calling that active ship combat is debatable; older capital and depot ships offer clearer comparisons.

    Q&A
  40. 2:25:05
    QuestionHow would the Falklands War change if Argentina had bought four Leander frigates and additional support ships?Answer

    Argentina would probably deploy them, and the larger fleet might change which major cruiser was exposed and sunk.

    Q&A
  41. 2:25:48
    QuestionAre old sailing-warship wrecks likely to remain preserved on the seabed?Answer

    They can survive for a long time, but limited surveys and heavy fishing mean intact remains cannot be assumed.

    Q&A
  42. 2:26:18
    QuestionWhat chance did Britain have of completing the Lion class if other capital-ship programs stayed on schedule?Answer

    Completion becomes much more likely if a Lion is already advanced when Britain discovers Yamato's eighteen-inch armament.

    Q&A
  43. 2:27:22
    QuestionWhat would a 1930s American modernization of Argentina's Rivadavia-class battleships include?Answer

    Likely five-inch/38 guns, better optical systems, machinery improvements, and internal rearrangement, constrained by money and topweight.

    Q&A