Video
Bruships 87: Books Found on My Travels, New Books & Christmas Recomendations
Study Bruships 87: Books Found on My Travels, New Books & Christmas Recomendations, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 9 Oct 2022, with 43 time notes. Topics include Book Recommendations, Live Q&A, Naval History.
Time notes
- 18:00A modeler's guide to HMS VictoryChapter
The first recommendation combines a compact history of HMS Victory with a survey of model kits, paint schemes, and scratch-building options.
- 22:20QuestionIf HMS Hood survived, would the Royal Navy still complete HMS Vanguard?AnswerQ&A
Probably yes; political and institutional inertia would favor completing a ship that embodied Britain's accumulated capital-ship knowledge.
- 23:48Shipwreck history through one hundred objectsChapter
Sam Willis's object-based shipwreck history leads into the wreck of Sea Venture, the settlement of Bermuda, and the castaways' eventual voyage to Jamestown.
- 28:51QuestionWould Britain trade one day at the start of the Second World War to modernize every Royal Navy ship to the best 1939 standard?AnswerQ&A
Yes; the fleet-wide gains in engines, radar, armor, and anti-aircraft weapons would far outweigh losing one day.
- 31:09QuestionWhat guns would make a strong pre-Second World War coastal defense for the Falkland Islands?AnswerQ&A
County-class eight-inch turrets, arranged in several three-turret batteries, would impose a formidable barrier to attack.
- 33:10How airliner engines became commercial systemsChapter
Powering the World's Airlines traces engine development from the 1930s and wartime production through turbojets, turbofans, and the economics of buying an airliner.
- 37:52QuestionWas HMS London's handling poor after modernization?AnswerQ&A
Its handling changed from race-car-like responsiveness to a rally car's need for more anticipation and tolerance of rougher conditions.
- 39:16QuestionWould modern cruise ships sent into a world war sail independently or in convoy?AnswerQ&A
Most would sail in convoy because they are too slow to operate safely alone; Queen Mary 2 might be an exception.
- 40:11QuestionShould the King George V class have used fifteen-inch or sixteen-inch guns instead of fourteen-inch weapons?AnswerQ&A
A high-quality fifteen-inch gun offers the strongest fleet-wide benefit because it could also modernize thirteen existing British capital ships.
- 42:53Military Heroes as warts-and-all biographyChapter
Brian Lightbody's Military Heroes is recommended for concise biographies that preserve their subjects' flaws, illustrated by racing driver and First World War ace Eddie Rickenbacker.
- 47:13QuestionWhat difference would old eight-inch Falklands batteries make during the 1982 invasion?AnswerQ&A
They could badly damage or even stop the invasion force, but maintaining them would require a much larger garrison and layered air defense.
- 53:57A technical owner's manual for wartime U-boatsChapter
A Haynes-style U-boat manual opens discussion of Type VII machinery, snorkels, and why late-war improvements could not overturn the adapting Allied anti-submarine system.
- 58:30QuestionDid the Type VII U-boat snorkel handle both intake and exhaust?AnswerQ&A
According to the featured Haynes manual, yes: it drew in fresh air and expelled diesel-engine air through the installation.
- 1:01:50The diplomatic battle around HMS AmethystChapter
Escape of the Amethyst portrays a ship captain forced into a tense political contest over safe conduct, responsibility, and British national standing during the Yangtze Incident.
- 1:11:36QuestionCould Britain build capital ships and escorts at the same time without slowing escort construction?AnswerQ&A
Both could be built in parallel, but capital-ship work would inevitably reduce how quickly escorts could be produced.
- 1:12:37QuestionWhat if the CIA knowingly sank a British ship with all hands and the attack became public?AnswerQ&A
It would cause a major alliance and presidential-control crisis, probably forcing the agency to be renamed and reorganized.
- 1:16:08Prefabricated escorts met established shipyard practiceNotable Point
A passage on wartime escort construction shows that prefabrication was as much an organizational challenge as a technical one in established British yards.
- 1:19:54QuestionIs the story about the cat rescued from Bismarck reliable?AnswerQ&A
The same cat is claimed to have turned up alive in too many later places, which makes the story doubtful.
- 1:20:07QuestionHow would Britain react if the CIA mistakenly bombed a British diplomatic site in a counterfactual 1984?AnswerQ&A
Britain would be extremely angry, but the incident would probably be resolved diplomatically because the two countries would remain allies.
- 1:20:35A visual route into Royal Navy camouflageChapter
Malcolm Wright's illustrated camouflage volumes are recommended as accessible visual guides covering cruisers, escorts, destroyers, and sloops such as the Black Swan class.
- 1:25:53QuestionWhy combine exhaust with the snorkel instead of discharging it underwater despite the back pressure?AnswerQ&A
A combined installation could be the more practical retrofit for an older Type VII, even though snorkel exhaust created development and detection tradeoffs.
- 1:31:07QuestionCan one country really stop another sovereign power from acting?AnswerQ&A
Usually not if the state is determined; an ally's restraint often supplies diplomatic cover for a decision the state already prefers.
- 1:36:54Sea Power and Victory in wartime imagesChapter
An Imperial War Museum picture book surveys maritime warfare through cruiser blockades, kite balloons, submarine chasers, and a captured submarine.
- 1:50:06QuestionIf the necessary inputs were available by the end of 1942, could an Audacious-class carrier commission in 1944?AnswerQ&A
Yes; that timing is plausible and the ship might even enter service earlier.
- 1:50:49Warspite's sailors and the Invergordon pay crisisChapter
Battleship Sailors uses HMS Warspite's crew to show how unequal pay cuts, rumor, and weakened trust produced the Invergordon unrest.
- 1:55:43Jacky Fisher, the lower deck, and naval modernizationChapter
Fisher's Face presents Admiral Jacky Fisher's affection for sailors, hostility to inherited status barriers, and belief that social reform supported combat effectiveness.
- 1:59:21QuestionWhat might happen if Zheng He's fleet met an early Portuguese fleet off West Africa?AnswerQ&A
The chronology must first be altered, and a cautious exchange or negotiation would be more likely than an immediate battle.
- 1:59:55QuestionDid the United States need new sixteen-inch shells because it had run out of Second World War ammunition?AnswerQ&A
New shells were required because wartime stocks could only be maintained for a limited time, even if many remained unused.
- 2:02:26QuestionWhat would change if triangular sails reached northern Europe one or two centuries earlier?AnswerQ&A
Longer-range sailing would probably begin earlier, but the immediate wider changes would be limited.
- 2:02:44QuestionWhy was the CIA pilot Alan Pope's missed attack on HMS Oryx so consequential?AnswerQ&A
The miss let the incident be set aside; hitting and sinking the British submarine would have created a serious alliance crisis.
- 2:03:32QuestionHow seriously did the Suez Crisis damage relations between Britain and the United States?AnswerQ&A
It fundamentally recast the relationship, replacing assumptions of equality with the language of a special friendship and influence beyond Britain's weight.
- 2:04:25QuestionCould an encounter with early Portuguese sailors lead Zheng He's fleet onward to Europe?AnswerQ&A
Possibly; after rounding the Cape the fleet might reach the Mediterranean and Europe, with outcomes ranging from contact to religious conflict.
- 2:05:50The Forgotten Dead and the purchase of a sunken ShermanChapter
Ken Small's The Forgotten Dead recounts the legal and bureaucratic campaign to buy a submerged Sherman tank as a memorial to American servicemen killed during wartime training.
- 2:13:48QuestionWhy did the French Navy not rebuild its carriers to British or American modernization standards?AnswerQ&A
France decided those conversions were unnecessary for its requirements and pursued other aviation choices instead.
- 2:15:29Preserving Mediterranean Fleet and Coastal Command magazinesNotable Point
Three fragile period magazines cover the Mediterranean Fleet, Coastal Command, and the Atlantic bridge, linking naval and air dimensions of maritime war.
- 2:22:02QuestionWhich warship designs would have been better never built?AnswerQ&A
HMS Captain is a leading example, although even disastrous ships and awkward ocean-going monitors taught navies something.
- 2:22:30QuestionWhy might Argentina expect Britain to sell it an Implacable-class carrier?AnswerQ&A
Britain might make the sale, but would probably balance it by selling the other carrier to Brazil.
- 2:23:32QuestionHow would small sailing ships armed with twelve or eighteen guns be rated?AnswerQ&A
Both would be unrated brigs of some type; the exact label would depend on rig, hull form, and purpose.
- 2:24:15QuestionWas HMS Victory the oldest ship used in combat as an anti-aircraft platform during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Possibly in a very broad sense, but calling that active ship combat is debatable; older capital and depot ships offer clearer comparisons.
- 2:25:05QuestionHow would the Falklands War change if Argentina had bought four Leander frigates and additional support ships?AnswerQ&A
Argentina would probably deploy them, and the larger fleet might change which major cruiser was exposed and sunk.
- 2:25:48QuestionAre old sailing-warship wrecks likely to remain preserved on the seabed?AnswerQ&A
They can survive for a long time, but limited surveys and heavy fishing mean intact remains cannot be assumed.
- 2:26:18QuestionWhat chance did Britain have of completing the Lion class if other capital-ship programs stayed on schedule?AnswerQ&A
Completion becomes much more likely if a Lion is already advanced when Britain discovers Yamato's eighteen-inch armament.
- 2:27:22QuestionWhat would a 1930s American modernization of Argentina's Rivadavia-class battleships include?AnswerQ&A
Likely five-inch/38 guns, better optical systems, machinery improvements, and internal rearrangement, constrained by money and topweight.