Q&A · 2:22:02-2:22:26

Can a bad warship still teach useful lessons?

HMS Captain is offered as an obvious design that was better left unbuilt, though even failed ships can expose valuable engineering and operational lessons.

Question

Which warship designs would have been better never built?

Short answer

HMS Captain is a leading example, although even disastrous ships and awkward ocean-going monitors taught navies something.

Notes

HMS Captain is the immediate example of a ship whose design should not have reached service. Even so, an unsuccessful warship is not historically worthless. Navies learn from failure as well as success, and a bad design can expose the limits of an engineering idea or operating concept. Some American Civil War ocean-going monitors were similarly troubled but revealing experiments.