Q&A · 1:54:35-1:55:07

Would a VC10 have avoided Nimrod's flaws?

A VC10-derived patrol aircraft could simplify tanker and transport fleets, but it would inherit many early jet-integration compromises associated with Nimrod.

Question

Would a VC10-based anti-submarine aircraft have been better than Nimrod?

Short answer

It might simplify logistics across several aircraft roles, but it could retain similar early-jet design compromises.

Notes

The Nimrod anti-submarine aircraft had design flaws. Replacing it with a VC10-derived platform might have offered commonality across tanker, transport, and maritime-patrol roles. That logistical attraction would not automatically remove the difficulty of combining an early jet platform with specialised mission equipment. The alternative could still be useful, but it would likely remain compromised in much the same way as Nimrod.