Q&A ยท 2:13:46-2:14:18

Why naval officers were excluded from treaty talks

Second London Naval Treaty negotiations sidelined naval officers after their technical objections were treated as obstruction.

Question

Why were naval officers excluded from the Second London Naval Treaty talks?

Short answer

Their repeated technical objections were treated as obstruction by politicians who wanted an agreement, so the naval specialists were removed from the talks.

Notes

Naval officers kept pointing out that proposed limits did not produce workable ships or coherent categories. Those technical objections were treated as obstruction, and the naval professionals were removed from the discussions. Even officers trying to improve the proposals were dismissed when their advice did not fit the desired agreement. The dispute concerned whether the treaty's proposed restrictions could produce practical ships.