Q&A · 2:17:30-2:21:30

A Coast Guard cutter hull for the US Navy frigate

The discussion examines how the Burke's price and capabilities shape arguments over a cutter-derived frigate, while reserving judgment on the final design.

Question

Does adopting a Coast Guard cutter hull weaken the US Navy's small-combatant force?

Short answer

The panel says the final design is needed before judging the result, then examines price and capability comparisons with the Arleigh Burke class.

Notes

The panel withholds a final judgment until the cutter-derived frigate's design is known. It describes the Arleigh Burke class as the comparison point that complicates proposals for both smaller and larger surface combatants. In this account, a frigate near a Burke's price attracts demands for the destroyer's capabilities, while a larger ship must explain what its extra size provides. The cutter proposal is discussed as an attempt to establish a lower price and a narrower initial mission. Participants also suggest that an unsuccessful naval variant could have a Coast Guard use, and that later frigates could then be compared with that smaller vessel. These are proposed outcomes discussed before the final design is established.