Complete directory
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
The proposed battle brings a larger and more complete British fleet than Jutland, making mutual devastation likely even if one side wins operationally.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Britain's decisive advantage is a concentrated fleet, and dividing it would let the entire High Seas Fleet defeat isolated groups in detail.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
The British would begin unloading almost immediately because troops ashore create the political and military pressure that forces Germany to respond.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Germany could threaten northern Britain, but the Channel barrage, mines, coastal destroyers, torpedo boats, and British submarines would make a Channel or Atlantic breakout difficult.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Blocking the Kiel Canal protects the Baltic lodgement but may prevent the very fleet battle Jellicoe wants, while attacking Wilhelmshaven means entering Germany's densest minefields.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
French leaders would probably resist at first because Britain had removed troops from the Western Front and secrecy limited advance consultation, with naval support more likely only after the result became clear.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Careful timing could trap ships that lack room to turn, while explosive- and mine-packed blockships would make clearing the obstruction slow and dangerous.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
He would withhold the plan until the Grand Fleet was entering the Danish Straits, then notify Russia in time for its Baltic Fleet to sortie later that day.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Destroying the High Seas Fleet and opening Russia's Baltic supply route could bring German peace talks in 1915 while transforming the reputations of the navy, Kaiser, Jellicoe, and Churchill.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Losses would continue, but Germany had only about thirty operational U-boats through much of 1915, and most enemy naval strength would already have been committed to the main battle.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Warspite would be a brand-new ship commissioned in March 1915, and her extraordinary historical survival record makes a confident prediction of her loss especially unpersuasive.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
A decisive battle in 1915 could remove the later wartime conditions behind American capital-ship orders and destroyer expansion.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Small 1915 U-boat classes with few torpedoes could add losses, but the campaign would be decided by a brutal short-range surface action.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
A decisive 1915 fleet battle changes later construction, weakens the case for the historical treaty system, and gives different navies the lead in carrier development.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Defenses developed later in the war cannot simply be assumed to exist for an operation proposed in the first half of 1915.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Seaplane carriers could provide reconnaissance, spotting, limited air defense, and some interception, but 1915 aviation was too immature to decide the campaign by itself.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Most versions sought northern Belgium or Germany's North Sea flank through Dutch waters, creating a neutrality problem, while some studies existed chiefly to show why the operation should not be attempted.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
The Russian admiral could preserve formal equality by asking where Jellicoe wanted his force, turning orders into accepted suggestions under a well-understood multinational naval convention.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Britain could promise Constantinople to Russia, offer it to Greece, or hold it pending a peace settlement, with a Russian award offering the greatest immediate support to Tsar Nicholas II.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
He could build a professional relationship and discuss readiness in general terms while withholding operational details that enemy intelligence might intercept.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
It has possibilities on paper, but its logistics and ability to attract political support remain doubtful.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
ANZAC and naval-division troops preserve surprise, while II Corps offers battle-hardened experience at the cost of a slower, more visible, and politically difficult redeployment.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Possibly, after enough correspondence established a relationship, but enemy analysts would also be watching for those hints.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Such operations could follow, but the Royal Navy would first need time to replace losses and restore a usable force structure.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Contemporary hull, armor, subdivision, boiler, and machinery limits made that balanced speed expensive and oversized, forcing designers to trade armor coverage against speed and firepower.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
A hypothetical triple-turret Queen Elizabeth illustrates how a wider, longer hull could create room for machinery and greater speed.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Jellicoe is judged the best available officer for the command, particularly for his coolness and calm.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
The Cabinet would have to approve, but Fisher and Churchill, a workable Jellicoe plan, Asquith's tendency to follow a strong coalition, and Lloyd George's interest in shortening the war could produce support.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Yes. An intact Royal Navy makes British defeat unlikely, so the Baltic gamble must justify risking the country's central strategic guarantee to meet its Entente commitments.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Queen Elizabeth was the prepared flagship choice, but battle position might force Jellicoe onto the nearest suitable ship, plausibly HMS Canada in the center of the line.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Losses would be horrendous, but it would be too strong to assume that every pre-dreadnought was destroyed.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Ramming is possible because a close, bitter fight around the Kiel Canal could collapse normal formation and fire-control distances.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
No. Vice-Admiral Cecil Burney and several other Grand Fleet officers, probably including Charles Madden, outranked Beatty in early 1915.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Only aircraft-directed fire makes that practical because terrain and smoke would hide ships in the canal from naval observers at ordinary engagement ranges.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
The class would probably move closer to a fast-battleship balance, while the battle's range and use of aircraft would determine whether designers emphasized maneuver, balanced fleets, or long-range fire.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Britain might still return the ship to Chile, or Canada could buy her as a memorial if she became closely associated with the victory.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
A more capable Ottoman government would recognize that strict neutrality offered its best chance of survival and might avoid entering the war altogether.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
The Soviet Union probably never forms because a supplied, victorious army preserves loyal regiments and blocks the conditions for a Bolshevik takeover, though a later moderate revolution remains possible.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
Germany would almost certainly face restrictions, but even without them political doubt about matching Britain would push the Kaiser toward cruisers and submarines rather than another equal battle fleet.
From What happens if instead of Gallipoli, Fisher gets Churchill to go for the Baltic? (Patreon) ·
An anonymised canal proposal failed basic feasibility because it was wide enough for ships but too shallow, underestimated the geography, and relied on unsupported economic claims.
One distinctive yacht or sail-training ship can support diplomacy, while amphibious capability requires enough useful hulls to sustain the fleet's commitments.
A fixed allowance of two carriers encouraged the Royal Navy to maximise the capability of each hull.
Every generation of military technology attracts predictions that one invention will displace everything else, and the answer rejects that recurring claim.
Yes. Vulnerable communications and supporting satellites make an exclusively drone-based force an unreliable assumption.
Removing bulk fuel and breaking up the ship in place is presented as a least-worst response to a difficult grounding.
The proposal supplies no convincing reason to accept the additional crew and infrastructure burden when surface shipping can already move the cargo.
A Russian fleet needs strong ports in the Northern, Pacific, Baltic, and Black Sea regions, reliable rail and canal links between them, and experienced personnel who stay in service.
Fish processing and surface work at hard-rock mines demanded strenuous labour from Cornish women.