Q&A · 1:38:52 The Barracuda class is presented as a capable conventional stopgap whose service horizon was shortened by nuclear attack submarines.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:39:21 A larger treaty allowance would make twin, dual-purpose 4.7-inch turrets plausible, but not remove the need for affordable numbers.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:41:53 A 1987 Falklands campaign with fewer British carriers becomes a problem of flight-deck capacity, landing support, and allied intervention.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:50:40 The class's speed shortfall came from accumulated weight and disappointing boiler efficiency more than from a fundamentally poor hull.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:51:53 Ranger and Wasp can be described as light fleet carriers, but both attempted full fleet-carrier capability on displacement that forced serious compromises.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:52:43 HMCS Haida and Britain's historic dockyards show how location, staffing, collections, and operating budgets shape museum-ship preservation.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:55:30 Armed fishing trawlers did fight submarines, and their stable gun platforms could surprise U-boat crews who chose to fight on the surface.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:57:38 Legal permission to build did not create the money, infrastructure, or political agreement needed to use every treaty allowance.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 1:58:24 Modern E-2 and E-3 aircraft would give the Allies an overwhelming information advantage over Axis forces.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:01:16 Human-powered paddle wheels could move a vessel, but they offered little answer to Royal Navy steam propulsion.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:02:32 A 15,000-ton British 9.2-inch cruiser would become a post-war armored-cruiser successor and push treaty cruiser limits upward.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:04:11 The analogy favors a British armored carrier because Galactica combines an air group with unusual protection and some gun power.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:05:11 Modern historiography dismantles romantic accounts of empire while rejecting imperial crimes as whataboutism that minimizes Nazism.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:12:04 Carrier aircraft do not remove the battleship's value until they can strike reliably in all weather with precision weapons.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:17:30 A notional British missile cruiser combines a large vertical-launch battery with aviation capacity and guns for endurance in a long war.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:19:35 The American crane mounting was one expression of a common search for high, stable positions for early anti-aircraft weapons.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:20:10 A forewarned interwar programme would improve escorts, carrier aviation, and gun readiness without pretending budgets allowed a wholly different fleet.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:25:40 A 27,000-ton super-cruiser category would invite aggressive British use of existing large-cruiser hulls and elastic treaty interpretation.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:28:20 Distance, existing British Pacific bases, and a preference to exclude rival powers made American Hawaii acceptable to Britain.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:29:13 Four Admirals and four British Number 13-type fast battleships could block the German retreat long enough for the Grand Fleet to close.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:31:06 At Nimitz scale, a flight-deck cruiser loses the rationale for being called a cruiser and becomes a large carrier with added strike weapons.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:33:00 American neutrality would not automatically prevent another world war and could produce a harsher post-war settlement with no Washington treaty.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:35:17 Hood would likely remain a museum ship, with fuller interpretation providing a better response to imperial history than removal.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:37:39 A lone Hanoi-class battleship would be dangerous locally but would invite a combined French carrier, submarine, and battleship response.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:40:43 Replacing the British carrier group with an American one gives the campaign vastly more airborne warning, strike power, and naval firepower.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:47:30 A USS Maine incident in British territory could produce calls for war, but naval imbalance makes an Anglo-American conflict politically implausible.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:49:49 The last American escort-carrier class offered the best purpose-built basis for retaining the type after wartime conversions left service.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:55:11 The Australian restoration appeared to remain active, although the update was cautious because direct project reports were no longer available.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 2:58:34 A loaned Iowa-class battleship would add commanding shore-bombardment power but would make American alignment with Britain impossible to disguise.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:00:35 Malta-class carriers would give the Falklands force a much stronger airborne-warning and fixed-wing aviation foundation.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:02:24 By the time Belfast could be converted, purpose-built or converted carrier hulls offered better helicopter capacity while Belfast remained valuable as a gun and command cruiser.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:03:38 Once Britain designs the helicopter cruiser from the keel up, the concept naturally converges on the Invincible class.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:06:49 The recommendations span illustrated histories of clipper ships and a nineteenth-century voyage diary.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:08:53 Containerized air-defence concepts face difficult integration requirements and were not funded to a mature operational system.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:09:34 Large flagships are the likeliest periodic museum selections because they combine status, usable interior space, and personal institutional memory.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:10:36 Large shore batteries remain more common than their public profile suggests, including systems associated with Norway, Finland, and Taiwan.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:15:47 Their woodworking skill would be valuable to wartime industry, especially Mosquito production, but modern literacy and technical training would be the limiting step.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:17:08 A time-displaced Ohio would be more useful as a conventional intelligence, special-operations, cargo, or anti-ship asset than as a nuclear weapon platform.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:20:30 Earlier large battleships would reward industrial capacity and could raise the cost of German naval competition before the First World War.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:23:27 A long-lived Hawker Siddeley Dynamics undersea weapon would reach the present only through successive upgrades; an unchanged system would have been replaced much earlier.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:24:04 The Seawolf-Virginia contrast is framed as a shift from an expensive peer-war submarine to a cheaper force built for a period of perceived advantage.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:25:25 Phil Carradice's modern study is recommended as an accessible starting point with routes into participant and contemporary accounts.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:29:11 Ending British control leaves the harder question of which people or state should receive the Chagos Islands.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:33:06 The naval struggle was less one-sided than hindsight suggests, but Japan still faced an attritional contest it was poorly placed to win.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:35:25 Ballistic missiles would change Long Beach from a notable cruiser into a strategic asset whose replacement becomes politically difficult.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:35:59 Port access and public acceptance matter more to nuclear merchant shipping than the number of hulls built.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:37:31 Retaining nuclear cruisers with Aegis would create a replacement requirement that could push Zumwalt toward nuclear power and energy weapons.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:41:22 A 12.7 cm dual-purpose mount might inflict a few more losses, but would not deter a determined British air strike.
From Bruships 165: I saw a Poodle with a Kalax Manual in his hand, walking through the moors of cornwall · 6 Oct 2024