Warrior versus a ship of the line
HMS Warrior and a top-rate ship of the line are compared by cost, gun power, machinery, and hull vulnerability.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Why ironclads are hard to turn into games
The ironclad era is historically rich but short on the iconic fleet actions that games often need.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Armstrong and Dahlgren gun reputations
Armstrong and Dahlgren gun reputations depended on engineering performance and the procurement stakes of naval service.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
The two-power standard as insurance against France and Russia
The two-power standard linked France, Russia, India, sea control, and the limits of an overland Russian supply chain.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Naval-constructor training as procurement protection
MIT naval-construction training shows why navies need officers who understand design, procurement, and damage control.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Riveting and caulking a watertight iron hull
Rivet spacing, plate fit, rust, and caulking tools made early iron warship joints watertight.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Could naval-constructor training hinder an officer's career?
Construction expertise needs senior support if a long training course is to help an officer's career.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Engineer officers and command in the ironclad era
The ironclad era opened a difficult route into command for officers with technical and engineering knowledge.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Which countries produced the best iron and armor
Purity, production methods, and alloy composition qualify comparisons between national iron and armor industries.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
When aluminum became practical for ships
Aluminum's low weight attracted designers long before cost, purity, and alloy quality made it practical for ships.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why Soviet titanium submarines were difficult to recycle
Recycling Soviet titanium submarines meant confronting difficult dismantling work and radioactive contamination.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why the World Wars crowd ironclads out of general histories
Market demand and word limits can push the quieter ironclad transition out of general naval histories.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Warrior's French rival and preserved career
Warrior's size and protection answer Gloire, while her later training and oil-jetty roles explain how the hull survived.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Medieval cogs and raised fighting platforms
Cogs and longboat-like medieval vessels developed aftercastles, possible forecastles, and raised archer platforms.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Do noble gases change an alloy?
The answer links a limited effect on alloy composition to noble gases' inert behavior.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
How alloy design changes warship armor
Interstitial and substitutional alloying explain how armor can combine strength with flexibility.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Specialist steels for tools, engines, and corrosion resistance
Alloy additions and impurity control explain improvements in cutting tools, engine parts, and naval materials.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Brass and bronze: composition and structure
Bronze and brass use different additions to copper; the question about their structural classification remains open.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Eighteen-inch guns, Furious, and hypothetical modern armor
The reply retains a role for 18-inch guns and explores how hull size might constrain their barrel length.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Modern armor against First World War guns
The first-hit claim depends on keeping the attacking guns historical; repeated impacts and modern weapons remove that assurance.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Can a stopped shell still damage machinery?
Armor resistance and internal shock protection remain separate parts of surviving a shell hit.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Long service, brittleness, and hull stress
Time at sea does not automatically embrittle metal, while waves and ship motion still impose structural loads.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Modern capacity for battleship armor plate
Producing dreadnought armor requires industrial capacity to roll very large plates as well as a suitable metal recipe.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
HY-80 and HY-100 names can outlast alloy changes
The answer distinguishes the continued use of HY labels from an unchanged submarine-steel formulation.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
From Monitor's turret to HMS Captain and Devastation
Turret firing arcs promised fewer guns, while Captain's loss and Devastation's layout exposed the costs of combining armament with sail.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Lissa's influence on rams and ahead fire
A rare ironclad battle encouraged ram bows and new firing-arc requirements, with costly consequences.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
French barbettes and tumblehome widened firing arcs
Amiral Duperre's four-gun layout used hull shape and barbettes to put three guns on important bearings.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Central batteries and en echelon gun layouts
Central-battery ships and beam-mounted guns show the search for ahead fire as gun nomenclature also changed.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Did the United States adopt the Zero's design?
The reply distinguishes operating captured Zeros from adopting their design.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why early steamships kept their sails
Coal consumption, operating costs, and naval seamanship traditions explain the long overlap between steam and sail.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Sirius and Great Western test Atlantic steam endurance
The Atlantic crossings show how purpose-built steamship design and a coal network affected endurance.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Paddle-wheel limits and HMS Rattler's screw trials
Feathering improved paddles, but rolling, loading, and gunfire exposure helped favor submerged screws.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Choosing sides for an ironclad wargame
Britain, France, and American monitors offer distinct ironclad fleets and design concepts for a hypothetical game.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Brunel's earnings and reinvestment
Brunel's substantial earnings were accompanied by substantial spending and investment.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Was the propeller inventor also the turret designer?
Ericsson's propulsion and turret work are linked tentatively, with uncertainty about a later development.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
The screw propeller was an invention race
Four near-simultaneous designers and rapid follow-on improvements complicate claims to the screw propeller.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
An experimental Italian aircraft and propeller choices
Propeller arrangement, engine power, and balance shape the assessment of an unconventional aircraft.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why iron hulls did not end combat losses
Iron hulls created an armor-versus-firepower competition rather than a permanent defensive advantage.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Torpedo boats and destroyer origins
Torpedo boats threatened blockades and prompted catchers, torpedo gunboats, and the early path toward destroyers.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Havoc, Hornet, and the first torpedo-boat destroyers
Havoc and Hornet established a fast, gun-armed answer to torpedo boats and quickly triggered higher speed requirements.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why early destroyers missed their trial speeds at sea
Loading, waves, vibration, and cramped accommodation qualify the early destroyers' advertised performance.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Churchill's drinking reputation and a famous retort
A familiar Churchill anecdote leads to a caution about political accusations and historical drinking habits.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Churchill and Royal Navy ship naming
Royal Navy naming preferences explain the absence of a current Churchill in the 2021 fleet.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Judging historical figures in context
Contemporary standards provide historical context without excusing every action or flattening people into heroes and villains.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Reginald Tyrwhitt and aggressive Harwich Force command
Tyrwhitt's preference for sea command and his force's night training explain the argument for his presence at Jutland.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Reginald Tyrwhitt's upbringing and naval path
Tyrwhitt's family connections and difficult schooling offer a social history of naval entry, with a caution about later autobiographical memory.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Why crews and officers belong in warship design history
Warships and personnel shape one another, while personal experience can influence which ships survive.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·
Could a prepared fleet have forced the Dardanelles?
Mine preparation, expendable hulls, reduced crews, sealed compartments, and temporary bulges define this Dardanelles counterfactual.
From Bruships 51: The Age of Iron ·