Q&A · 2:37:58 Hood lacks a completed same-generation battleship counterpart, but that absence does not make her one.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:41:31 A 1940 strategy book revised in 1941 shows the wartime demand for theory and the persistence of older naval debates.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:43:13 Without the Washington treaty timing, British cruiser categories and gun calibers might have developed around much larger ships.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:48:39 A cruiser version of the Vanguard approach could reuse upgraded 12-inch turrets from scrapped capital ships on new hulls.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:49:16 A Second World War-era naval strategy text treats oil fuel as a logistics question inseparable from sea control.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:51:25 A wartime defence of oil fuel combines protected shipping routes with access to several producing countries.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:58:58 The carrier's fame protected her from atomic testing, although it did not secure her preservation.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:00:08 Roskill combines respect for earlier naval theorists with revision of their arguments, while showing how closed Jutland papers still constrained research in 1961.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:12:27 If Yorktown had survived Midway, the US Navy's need for the British carrier Victorious would have been lower, though reinforcement could still appeal.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:13:19 Britain accepted the political cost of occupying Iceland because even a low-probability German foothold posed an unacceptable Atlantic risk.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:22:41 The familiar decisive-battle label obscures a wider Japanese interception-and-attrition system and the problems of reading doctrine through translation.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:29:25 Gorshkov's Soviet perspective illustrates why universal strategic ideas still produce different force priorities in different states.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:33:44 Gorshkov connects maritime strategy with pollution agreements and the movement of contaminants through marine resources and food supplies.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:41:07 Competition over fish stocks connects food security with sea power, while Gorshkov provides an earlier example of fishing fleets in strategic thought.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:43:46 A weak reputation can create a political dilemma when an LCS confronts lower-level maritime coercion with stronger US forces behind it.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:47:03 Western readers had reason to study Gorshkov as an adversary's strategic argument even when they expected Soviet bias.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:48:03 Visible Soviet prototypes could suggest a technological lead when unequal access to computing was pushing designers toward different development methods.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:51:03 The LCS might have fared better as a modest modern sloop using a proven modular system than as the revolutionary ship its program advertised.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:55:56 Warships retain windows because direct human vision still matters.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:56:28 A disputed film prompts a comparison between the Bradley's original transport role and the armed infantry fighting vehicle that emerged.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:59:36 The Swordfish emerged from informal discussions and merging requirements years before the later specification often treated as its starting point.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Chapter · 4:03:44 Cable's Gunboat Diplomacy explains why naval forces can offer political options between inaction and all-out war.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:08:33 Alternative suppliers, unreliable proxies, and difficult access constrain several forms of limited coercion before naval options enter the comparison.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:10:24 The critique of coercive air power distinguishes physical damage, popular morale, and leaders' decisions to end a war.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:15:53 Cable uses French operations during the Algerian struggle to distinguish the legal infringement of interception from the political reaction it produces.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:17:29 The wish to preserve an Invincible-class carrier came too late to save one of the ships.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:18:42 Air-power theory after the First World War did not abandon attacks on civilians; Douhet openly advocated escalating them with chemical and biological weapons.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:19:30 Hypothetical G3 conversions are preferred to the Courageous-group conversions, while a purpose-built 27,000-ton carrier remains a separate competing option.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:19:54 A large forward gun preserves the visible gunboat effect even on a ship armed mainly with missiles.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:22:50 At-sea VLS reloading presents an engineering problem, while the explanation offered for small missile stocks is funding.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:25:29 Stronger missile containers are considered possible, but their practical development remains unfinished.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Chapter · 4:26:21 Rapid growth in surface deployments, merchant support, foreign port services, and concentrated crisis deployments expanded Soviet naval influence.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:32:59 Overseas port access can support peacetime naval influence even where a fleet lacks a large dedicated logistics train.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:36:06 Antelope's loss illustrates the limits of magazine protection when an unexploded bomb detonates inside a ship and starts spreading fires.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:38:51 Containers simplify packaging, but ship stability, heavy lifts, and sea conditions still constrain replacing missile modules.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:40:28 A preference for retaining four Type 45s is weighed against buying more Type 83s, alongside an aspirational fleet of twelve ships in each planned class.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:45:45 A flag state has a say, but changing registration, ownership, and orders from a warship can all affect a merchant ship's wartime movements.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:47:21 Delayed LCS mission packages, higher costs, and construction problems show how a modular fleet proposal lost much of its original scale. Zumwalt provides a parallel case.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 4:49:56 Zumwalt promised quiet running, integrated electric power, precise shore bombardment, and a much smaller crew. Its early tumblehome criticism is qualified by subsequent refinement.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:53:34 Royal Navy Type-number bands provide clues to intended roles, while Type 26's quiet machinery and sonar show why its broad branding still rests on an anti-submarine design.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:57:03 Size and the length of time a vessel can sustain itself at sea are the main distinctions offered between fast attack craft and corvettes.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 4:57:38 A comparison with a fishing boat is meaningless unless it identifies which size and configuration of fishing vessel.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 5:00:00 Naming warships after major cities can raise the political cost of cancelling them without making shipbuilding an automatic vote winner.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 5:01:40 A personal reaction to the Peppa Pig speech controversy illustrates an argument about political ridicule: criticism can alienate people who identify with its target.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 5:08:18 False AIS reports are a longstanding form of maritime deception and are likely to remain part of warship tracking.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 5:08:32 Officers seldom carry pistols outside beach teams, sentry duty, and some boarding work. The Glock 17 is tentatively identified as the service sidearm then in use.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 5:10:44 A speculative answer about spacecraft weapons puts avoiding hull damage ahead of choosing an ordinary service pistol.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021
Q&A · 5:13:24 British servicemen probably carried revolvers when they were standard issue, although the comparison with Patton's distinctive weapons remains general.
From Bruships 63: The Writing Theorists - Corbett & Mahan, Richmond & Simms, Cable & Gorshkhov · 5 Dec 2021