Video
Tsingtao 1939: WWII but in January & against Japan - P5c Introduction to Patreon Video 4
Study Tsingtao 1939: WWII but in January & against Japan - P5c Introduction to Patreon Video 4, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 17 Aug 2020, with 19 time notes. Topics include Counterfactual History, Imperial Japanese…
Time notes
- 0:08A Far Eastern war changes British air prioritiesChapter
An early Far Eastern war would make British rearmament more naval from the outset, altering the balance between home defence and Fleet Air Arm production.
- 3:27Germany weighs attacks on supply convoys to Britain and SingaporeNotable Point
German planners could attack US-backed supply convoys bound for Britain and Singapore, tying commerce raiding to American neutrality, Soviet trade, and access to oil.
- 5:37A Black Sea role for the Deutschland classNotable Point
The enclosed Black Sea could make Germany's Deutschland-class panzerschiffe more useful because their heavy guns would dominate likely opponents and short passages would spare unreliable diesels.
- 7:39Dido-class cruisers expose the cost of treaty-limited hullsNotable Point
Comparing the Dido class with 4.5-inch conversions of older cruisers exposes the cost of undersized treaty-era British hulls.
- 8:52A Pacific war accelerates British fleet constructionChapter
A Pacific-first conflict would prioritise British capital ships, carriers, cruisers, and long-range destroyers instead of delaying them for the Atlantic escort emergency.
- 10:12Fleet carriers and naval fighters gain priorityNotable Point
Accelerated carrier completion would make Britain's choice of naval fighter and strike aircraft central to the counterfactual war.
- 13:32American carrier-fighter options before the CorsairNotable Point
American engines and fighter projects show what Britain might obtain if it requested carrier aircraft on a different wartime timetable.
- 15:37Defeat Japan, enforce a blockade, then redeployChapter
After a major victory over Japan, the proposed strategy shifts from carrier attacks on shipyards and a cruiser-submarine blockade to a rapid return of the battle fleet.
- 16:28Ernest King faces a British-led naval warNotable Point
With Japan already defeated by Britain, Ernest King's preference for an American-led Pacific war collides with the return of a victorious, battle-experienced Royal Navy.
- 19:11An experienced Royal Navy enters the MediterraneanNotable Point
A Royal Navy hardened in the Pacific could arrive in the eastern Mediterranean with carrier-strike experience, improved anti-aircraft arrangements, and a decisive numerical advantage.
- 20:17American sea power without its Pacific foundation mythNotable Point
If Britain won the decisive naval battles first, the United States might enter the wider war as a supplier without the same formative Pacific combat experience.
- 22:26Italian air power faces a Pacific-tested carrier fleetNotable Point
Early Japanese and Italian aircraft would face British naval fighters, armoured carrier decks, and a fleet already trained in a major campaign.
- 27:59Japan seeks an early decisive battleNotable Point
Japanese pride, limited prospects for reinforcement, and the opening-war situation could push the fleet to seek battle despite losses.
- 29:31HMS Enterprise's unexplained missile-jamming refitNotable Point
A March 1944 Devonport refit entry prompts a cautious attempt to identify HMS Enterprise's "missile jamming gear" and its possible connection to Fritz X.
- 30:17Henderson's pre-war refit plans become availableNotable Point
Keeping Reginald Henderson in post would give the counterfactual Royal Navy an advocate with pre-existing ideas for improving treaty-constrained ships.
- 31:56Rebuilding E-class cruisers for raider and convoy workChapter
The proposed E-class rebuild combines twin six-inch turrets, 4.5-inch guns, and close-range anti-aircraft weapons to create useful second-line cruisers.
- 36:38A stronger Soviet Union complicates German war plansNotable Point
A war against Germany cannot remain a maritime blockade: a Soviet Union already fighting alongside the Allies would alter the calculations over Poland and eastern Europe.
- 39:45Balkan river crossings test German logisticsNotable Point
German operations in the Balkans would be constrained by supply routes and a difficult opposed river crossing, despite how simple the plan looks on a map.
- 41:24Why the Swordfish can survive unexpected damageNotable Point
The Swordfish's surprising combat record is linked to the different damage behaviour of its fabric-covered structure.