Q&A · 2:56:16-2:57:15

Yamato cannot change battleship perception alone

A Yamato question explains why better dual-purpose guns probably would not overcome massed air attack or rewrite later battleship memory.

Question

If Yamato had better 100 mm dual-purpose guns, could she have forced a battleship fight and changed postwar views of battleships?

Short answer

Probably not; numbers and air support mattered more, and later battleship memory was reshaped well after the war.

Notes

Yamato's problem included the weight of aircraft attacking a battleship that lacked proper air support, not only the quality of her anti-aircraft fit. British, American, and Soviet observers understood that battleships and air support were stronger together than either arm operating alone. Even a battleship fight would not necessarily change later perceptions, which were heavily shaped by retrospective arguments from the 1970s and 1980s onward.