Q&A ยท 54:46-57:18

What would Yamato look like in an 18-inch treaty world?

An 18-inch starting point for treaty limits would change the fleet programmes against which Yamato was designed.

Question

What would Yamato look like if the earlier gun race had produced British 18-inch battleships?

Short answer

The treaty system and subsequent building programmes would change so extensively that Yamato would be a fundamentally different design.

Notes

A Royal Navy already operating 18-inch capital ships at the end of the First World War would change the starting point for treaty negotiations. An 18-inch ceiling could replace the historical 16-inch baseline, with other navies wanting permission to build ships to match it. A later British reduction in calibre might then mean 16- or 16.5-inch guns, rather than the historical 14-inch choice. Yamato would emerge from such different assumptions that no simple modification of the historical design is offered. Italian Caracciolo plans would face a much stronger comparison, Germany's later battleships would struggle to compete, and the very large Tillman proposals would seem less exceptional.