Q&A ยท 1:21:09-1:26:14

Why treaty export construction differed from disposing of warships

The export objection is answered by distinguishing treaty-compliant new construction from disposal and wartime seizure of foreign orders.

Question

Did the naval treaties prohibit building warships for countries outside the treaty system?

Short answer

No. The cited construction clause permits treaty-compliant foreign orders, while separate provisions concern disposal and taking over undelivered ships during war.

Notes

A claim that the treaties banned construction for non-signatories prompts a reading of the relevant clauses. Article 15 is used to show that export construction was permitted within the limits for comparable treaty ships, with a 27,000-ton ceiling for carriers. The later explanation distinguishes that new construction from transferring a navy's existing warships under the disposal restriction. A further wartime clause prevents taking over another customer's undelivered ship. The interpretation therefore separates the design limits, disposal restrictions and treatment of foreign orders during war.