Was Tirpitz substantially tougher than the battleships attacked at Pearl Harbor?
Short answerNot necessarily. Her Norwegian anchorage, stronger air defenses, and the absence of a six-carrier concentrated strike made her a harder target.
NotesTirpitz's durability cannot be read directly from the damage record. Aircraft attacking her in a fjord relied mainly on bombs because torpedo approaches were difficult. They also faced stronger defenses than the surprised fleet at Pearl Harbor. The Royal Navy never concentrated six carriers for a single opening blow, so the comparison reflects operational circumstances as much as armor.