Q&A · 3:56:41-3:57:27

The Washington Treaty becomes a personhood dispute in Azur Lane

The historical tonnage bargain becomes an ethical and legal crisis because scrapping a ship may mean killing or coercing a person.

Question

How would the Washington Naval Treaty work in Azur Lane if warships were sentient beings?

Short answer

The historical tonnage bargain becomes an ethical and legal crisis because scrapping a ship may mean killing or coercing a person.

Notes

Crimson Echo supplies the fictional setting for a question about sentient warships refusing to be scrapped. The initial response distinguishes the historical Washington Naval Treaty from a new agreement made after those beings exist. If the scenario instead places sentient ships in the treaty period, scrapping becomes a question about their rights. A state may have created a being as a weapon, but that does not settle whether it can order the being to accept destruction. The exchange leaves that conflict between military command and personhood unresolved.