Q&A · 1:23:12-1:25:05

Would Queen Elizabeth adopt triple turrets or better boilers?

Improved boilers are preferred in the scenario because Britain already had relevant machinery experience.

Question

Would the Queen Elizabeth class gain triple turrets or small-tube boilers in this scenario?

Short answer

Small-tube boilers are judged more likely, potentially with five twin turrets and a speed of about 25-26 knots.

Notes

The proposed Queen Elizabeth alternatives include triple turrets or small-tube boilers. The expectation favours boilers because the Royal Navy had already tested progressively smaller-tube machinery elsewhere. Triple heavy-gun turrets lacked the same history of British service experience at this point. The comparison with later triple 4-inch mounts illustrates the preference for trying an arrangement on a smaller scale first. Retaining five twin turrets would give ten guns, with an estimated 25-26 knots despite an initial aim of 28. The boiler improvement is also qualified as period machinery, rather than the more developed equipment of much later ships.