Q&A · 1:08:56-1:09:24

Could Japan afford a capital-ship race against G3 and N3?

A short counterfactual answer connects escalating gun calibre and displacement to the unequal economic capacity behind an interwar naval race.

Question

Could Japan afford to build ships large enough to compete in a world where the British G3 and N3 classes entered service?

Short answer

Japanese leaders might have attempted it politically, but the cost could have broken the Japanese economy.

Notes

A British N3 with 18-inch guns would move the benchmark that Japan's next battleship had to meet or exceed. The political will to continue might still have existed, especially in a prestige-driven naval competition. The financial base was the limiting factor: sustaining such a response would have been deeply problematic and might have broken the Japanese economy. The exchange separates the ability to draw a larger design from the ability to fund a fleet program around it.