Q&A · 2:09:27-2:10:00

Why not sacrifice old battleships against the Dardanelles mines?

The answer separates willingness to lose obsolete ships from the much harder decision to expose thousands of sailors to avoidable deaths.

Question

If old pre-dreadnoughts were expendable, why did the Allies hesitate after losing some of them in the Dardanelles?

Short answer

The hulls could be risked, but their large crews could not; added mine protection offered a better way to use the ships aggressively.

Notes

Obsolete pre-dreadnoughts could be treated as expendable matériel, but the same label did not apply to the thousands of people serving aboard them. The proposed answer is preparation: sacrifice some speed, add large anti-mine or anti-torpedo bulges, and put the protected old ships at the front. HMS Queen Elizabeth could then remain behind them to provide modern heavy-gun support and counter Goeben if necessary. The exchange adds the human constraint missing from a simple ship-count calculation.