Could a British capital ship place Q turret above X and Y in a three-level superfiring arrangement aft?
Short answerIt was theoretically possible, but Britain was unlikely to accept the resulting hull stresses and pitching problems.
NotesA tall concentration of heavy turrets involves more than fitting the guns into a profile. Their barbettes, magazines, and concentrated weight transmit large loads into the hull. Raising and clustering them aft could create structural discontinuities and worsen the ship's motion in a seaway. A period British design would therefore be more likely to use the conventional arrangement, even though the alternative can be drawn. Geometric possibility does not settle whether a naval architect would consider the ship operable.