Q&A · 8:22:13-8:25:31

Could naval treaties survive without national fleet ratios?

An alternative treaty would regulate individual ship characteristics while letting states choose how many compliant vessels to fund.

Question

What happens if Britain and America want to preserve the treaty but France and Italy want different terms?

Short answer

The system could break down, or an agreement could retain limits on individual ships while abandoning national fleet totals.

Notes

The question imagines disagreement among Britain, the United States, France, and Italy after a Japanese war disrupts the treaty framework. One outcome is that each country pursues its own programme. An alternative agreement would retain limits on each ship's size and weapons while removing cumulative national allowances. A 16-inch maximum is one illustrative limit, with the precise terms left to negotiation. This arrangement would allow different numbers of compliant ships without requiring agreement on national ratios.