Q&A · 3:13:57-3:17:34

Heavy naval guns regain value when missile magazines empty

Two linked answers defend larger guns for shore bombardment and warn that sustained war can exhaust expensive missile inventories.

Question

Could navies return to heavy gunfire-support ships, or do missiles and 5-inch guns already cover the mission?

Short answer

Heavy guns could return once navies confront how quickly missiles are expended; a 5-inch gun may be adequate, but an 8-inch system offers additional sustained-fire advantages.

Notes

Cancelling an 8-inch autoloading naval gun because a 5-inch weapon seemed adequate is described as short-sighted. Greater range and shell weight could still matter, especially once a navy confronts how quickly missiles may be consumed in a prolonged, high-intensity conflict. An individually capable precision weapon does not provide the same magazine depth as sustained gunfire support.