What if National Shipbuilders Security had mothballed closed yards instead of demolishing and restricting them?
Short answerBritain would likely have reactivated major yards during rearmament, gaining valuable carrier, cruiser, capital-ship, armor, and steel capacity.
NotesPreserving the closed yards could allow major reactivation around 1937-38, when rearmament created demand for large warships. Beardmore on the Clyde and Palmer's at Jarrow are the principal examples. Palmer's construction of Queen Mary supports the suggestion that an Illustrious-sized carrier could fit, although the available length would be tight. Beardmore had already built Argus and battleships, while its Parkhead foundry could also help relieve shortages of capital-ship armour. Jarrow's integrated works took production from iron ore to a finished steel ship within one company. Preserving these facilities would retain useful steelmaking and armour capacity alongside the building berths.