Q&A ยท 3:43:46-3:45:53

Colossus and Victoria: awkward capital-ship choices

Colossus's transitional design and Victoria's mixed-calibre armament invite comparison with a larger, four-gun Victoria alternative.

Question

What was a favorite conspicuously misguided design moment among the great-power navies?

Short answer

Colossus and Victoria are the British examples, particularly Victoria's mixed main armament and the alternative of a larger hull with four 16.25-inch guns.

Notes

Colossus looks awkward beside other contemporary Royal Navy projects and the Admiral class that quickly followed. Victoria combined her large forward armament with a different-calibre gun aft. A proposed alternative is a longer, slightly larger hull with four 16.25-inch guns, arranged as an improved Admiral-type ship. In that counterfactual, the later Trafalgars could continue the same development instead of returning to 13.5-inch guns.