Which five gun calibers would you choose for an entire navy at the start of the Second World War?
Short answerThe proposed set is 40 mm, 4.5-inch, 6-inch, 9.2-inch, and 16-inch weapons for light AA through battleship armament.
NotesClarke chooses 40 mm for a weapon expected to remain useful throughout the war. For general-purpose work, he prefers 4.5-inch guns as a compromise between the different advantages of 5-inch weapons. Six-inch guns equip the light cruisers, while 9.2-inch guns give the heavy cruisers a distinct capability despite the availability of more modern 8-inch weapons. The battleship choice is 16-inch, partly because a super-heavy shell design becomes available during the period. A preferred 16.5-inch option falls outside the exercise's available choices.