Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:23:08-2:23:46

A caveat on Fighters over the Fleet

Fighters over the Fleet is not rejected as a bad book, but its structure repeatedly returns to the same material.

Book ReviewsFighters Over the FleetHistorical MethodNaval AviationNorman Friedman
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Are any Norman Friedman books worth avoiding?

Short answer

None outright, but Fighters over the Fleet can feel repetitive because of the way its subject is structured.

Notes

Norman Friedman's books are treated as generally consistent in quality, and no title is named as one readers should categorically avoid. Fighters over the Fleet is the caution because its structure repeatedly brings the narrative back over the same ground. The book remains good despite that repetition. Readers can therefore approach it with realistic expectations without mistaking a repetitive structure for weak research.