Should Britain have accepted F-35B and omitted catapults from the Queen Elizabeth class?
Short answerYes, if Britain also fields aviation-capable LHDs so one aircraft type can use multiple flight decks.
NotesThe F-35B choice makes strategic sense as part of a broader aviation fleet rather than as an isolated carrier decision. A catapult aircraft would tie the fixed-wing air group to the Queen Elizabeth-class decks, while separate amphibious ships would need a different aviation system. If Britain operated three aviation-capable LHDs alongside its two carriers, one short-take-off aircraft type could move between all five decks. That flexibility could keep at least two flight decks available and turn commonality into an operational advantage.