Q&A ยท 3:17:47-3:21:54

Could triple 18-inch turrets fit an Iowa-class barbette?

The panel doubts that three 18-inch guns could become a practical drop-in replacement for an Iowa-class triple 16-inch turret.

Question

Could Kentucky and Illinois carry triple 18-inch guns in the same barbettes as the Iowa-class Mark 7 turrets?

Short answer

The panel finds twins plausible but remains unconvinced that triples would be practical; the cited plans are not established here as a workable installation.

Notes

The claim that Kentucky and Illinois could receive triple 18-inch/48 guns in existing Iowa-class barbettes meets considerable doubt. Twin 18-inch mountings seem plausible to the panel, while fitting triples may depend on a theoretical arrangement that was never developed into a practical installation. Larger projectiles and propellant charges would require larger, slower hoists and more ammunition space. The extra two inches of bore therefore understate the change in handling requirements. The speakers have not established what the cited plans actually prove and suggest that a study might even have been intended to show why the arrangement should not be built.